Who's Making All the Money in the Porn Industry? | The Global Story
Who really profits from online porn? A journalist's six-year hunt uncovers Wall Street debt, a secret owner and how porn shaped the entire internet.
The pornography industry is worth tens of billions of dollars. Some statistics suggest that at peak times, about 10% of all internet traffic is pornography. The era of individual porn barons such as Hugh Hefner and Larry Flynt has ended. Financial Times reporter Patricia Nelson spent six years investigating who profits from the industry and how its scale has changed the way the internet works. Her book, Guilty Pleasure, examines how the logic of pornography shaped the internet.
Origins of the Investigation
Nelson began covering the industry in 2019, when the UK first attempted to introduce age verification. Her interest focused on MindGeek, which owned Pornhub, YouPorn, and other "tube sites," where most people now consume pornography. Public information about the company was almost nonexistent. It was practically impossible to determine how MindGeek made money, who owned it, or where its profits went.
Her research found that MindGeek had grown large after being financed with heavy debt from major institutional investors on Wall Street. The company had also been secretly taken over by a former Goldman Sachs banker whom almost no one in the industry knew existed. Porn trade journalists she contacted dismissed her as a conspiracy theorist when she raised the possibility that the company had been sold to an unknown owner.
Nelson states that many of the people profiting from pornography are far removed from the performers who make it. Many of these owners, including the man who secretly took over MindGeek, sought anonymity and cited their right to privacy. Performers, by contrast, appear naked in front of the public. Once content featuring a person is online, removing it can be very difficult.
The Golden Age and the VHS Era
Nelson describes the "golden age" of pornography as the 1970s and 1980s in the San Fernando Valley of California, which the industry nicknamed "Silicon Valley." The name referred to silicone breast implants, which became popular in pornography in the 1980s and 1990s. The Valley served as the global hub for pornography production and operated as a parallel universe to Hollywood. Producers, directors, and performers made ambitious films. Some film scholars have compared these productions to musicals, with sex scenes functioning as the song-and-dance numbers.
The industry grew out of the sexual revolution of the late 1960s and the "porno-chic" era, when mainstream cinemas screened pornographic films. Andy Warhol made a pornographic film during this period. The introduction of the VHS format then moved pornography into the home. Consumers could rent or buy films instead of visiting cinemas or buying magazines. Pornography became less visible in public life, but the industry grew. Revenue came from VHS, DVD sales, and hotel pay-per-view rentals, which generated significant income.
The Arrival of Online Pornography
In the 2000s, online pornography changed the industry. Content that had once required a trip to a video store or a top shelf became available to anyone, anywhere, at any time.
Tube sites offered pornography for free. Traditional producers lost substantial revenue because their films were copied and uploaded without payment. Anger toward the tube sites was intense, but few people knew who controlled them.
Fabian Thylmann, a German technology entrepreneur, was central to this shift. In 2012, the industry held one of its major annual conferences, which Nelson compares to the Oscars of the porn industry. Thylmann was scheduled to deliver a keynote speech. So many attendees tried to enter the room that the speech started 30 minutes late. It was Thylmann's first public appearance before an audience that was highly hostile toward him. He owned Manwin, the company behind Pornhub and many other tube sites that had disrupted the industry.
Thylmann wore a grey hoodie and appeared to imitate the look of Mark Zuckerberg, according to one observer. Before he could begin his remarks, some people in the front row hummed the ominous theme from Star Wars associated with Darth Vader. He opened by saying he was not the villain they believed him to be. He then explained why his business decisions made economic sense. Thylmann appeared to misread the anger in the room.
Financing and Business Model
Thylmann wanted to address rumors about the source of his funding. He had taken control of several major pornography businesses in his late twenties or early thirties, and many people questioned how a developer had obtained such capital. Some rumors claimed the money came from the Mafia, which had been involved in the industry before pornography became more legal.
Nelson reports that Thylmann's early backers included JP Morgan, Fortress Investment Group, and Cornell University. Two bankers assembled these investors, and Thylmann persuaded them by offering large returns if they supplied the cash he needed. The pitch presented pornography as incidental. The business, the backers were told, was an attention business and an internet business.
Thylmann never built a pornography website. He developed one of the first affiliate marketing software packages. The tool allowed website owners to track where users clicked. This gave Thylmann insight into the back end of many pornography sites. He could determine how to optimize advertising and how to direct user attention from one page to the next.
Affiliate marketing worked as follows. A studio uploaded a 10-minute excerpt of a film to Pornhub. Viewers who wanted more followed a link to another website and purchased a subscription or the film. The studio then paid Pornhub a share of the sale, similar to a finder's fee. Nelson says that early tube site entrepreneurs described this arrangement as an evolution. Studios first tried to have their content removed from tube sites. Over time, they accepted that they had to collaborate. Some tube sites took as much as 50% of subscription revenue from the studios, and many studios could not sustain these fees. Nelson says that the fees put some studios out of business.
Affiliate marketing extends well beyond pornography. News organizations, including the BBC, publish content on X, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook to capture attention, then pay these platforms when readers click through and purchase journalism. Amazon grew into a dominant company largely through its affiliate program, which paid website owners when links to Amazon produced purchases. OnlyFans also uses affiliate marketing. Its performers can share other performers' content and receive a cut when they direct fans to someone else. OnlyFans still operates a finder's fee: a performer who signs up a new creator receives 5% of that creator's earnings in the first year.
Sale and Restructuring
In 2013, Thylmann sold Manwin after he was arrested for tax evasion. His lenders, who effectively controlled the company, removed him because they considered his public profile a liability. They also wanted to remain anonymous. Once the names of the investors who had financed the company became public, they withdrew and sold their debt. Thylmann announced that he would sell the company to his executive team, which included Feras Antoon and David Tassillo, and to an unnamed investor.
The company was renamed MindGeek. Nelson describes it as a closed organization. Its chief executive gave one interview during this period, and executives gave press quotes without evidence that these individuals existed.
When Nelson began her research in 2019 or 2020, the company was called MindGeek, and no one knew who controlled it. She notes that the lack of public knowledge reflects broader social avoidance of the subject. Pornography is widely taboo, and few people ask who owns the companies that shape online sexual culture.
Corporate Structure and the Hidden Owner
MindGeek's structure resembled that of many multinational corporations. Subsidiaries operated in several jurisdictions. Intellectual property was held by a subsidiary in a low-tax jurisdiction, in this case Luxembourg. The parent company paid the subsidiary to use the brands it owned. The parent therefore reported little profit and sometimes posted losses, while the revenue flowed to the low-tax entity.
Nelson found an anomaly in this structure. MindGeek owned only one-third of some of these subsidiaries. An unnamed shareholder owned the remaining two-thirds. After a conversation with a person who had been involved in financing the company, she learned the owner's identity. The source said: "Mind Geek has a secret owner." He named Bernard Burgemar.
Nelson could find no records for that name. She asked the source to repeat the spelling and then searched again. She found one reference: a 10-year-old court case that identified Bernard Burgemar as a director of Red Tube, a tube site that MindGeek bought around the time Thylmann left the company.
A few weeks later, a contact of Cynthia Mertru, an investigative journalist on the FT's investigations desk, told Mertru that Bernard Burgemar was an alias. The man's real name was Bernd Bergmeier. Bergmeier had a wife, children, and former colleagues. He had been a Goldman Sachs banker and had retired years earlier. He was Austrian and had moved back to Vienna, where he worked as a financial adviser. He encountered the founders of Red Tube, who were trying to sell the site quickly because one of them had fallen in love with a Catholic woman and wanted to leave the business. Bergmeier decided to buy the company outright.
Nelson says Bergmeier had no experience in the pornography industry. He did not know how to run one of the most visited websites in the world. He contacted other porn platform owners and asked to take them to lunch to learn how the business operated.
Data and the Changing Business Model
After MindGeek's acquisition, the company's operating priorities changed. Banner advertising had been a major source of revenue for pornography sites and other user-generated platforms. Rising concern about privacy led many users to install ad blockers. Smartphones then became the main devices for viewing content, and banner advertising on mobile screens performed poorly. The business shifted toward analytics, using data to learn as much as possible about each user.
Nelson describes user-generated platforms as one-sided mirrors. They collect large amounts of data, including private impulses, and use it to shape what users see and keep them on the site as long as possible. As the company learned more about users, it disclosed less about its ownership and operations.
MindGeek and similar companies trade user data. They share data with other companies to build online profiles of individuals, which are then bought and sold as commodities. Nelson says that leaks show personal data can be linked to individuals. A leak from Pornhub, which occurred a few months before the interview, linked sexual preferences and search histories to email addresses. She states that internet companies know far more about users than users often realize.
MindGeek also pioneered what researchers call data-led creativity. The company analyzed what users clicked and used those patterns to decide which content to produce. Amazon, Apple, and Spotify use similar methods today.
OnlyFans and Parasocial Intimacy
Nelson says pornography is returning to a paid model. Pornhub represented free pornography. OnlyFans and similar platforms have expanded paid content and custom material, and they monetize what Nelson calls parasocial intimacy, in which consumers pay for the illusion of a relationship with people they see on screen.
OnlyFans combines the cam model with the structure of a social media feed. Camming began with webcams in the early to mid-1990s, when sex workers talked to customers, often on the other side of the world, through a screen. OnlyFans uses a feed format, and most interaction takes place through text rather than video calls.
Nelson argues that cam performers were the first to curate online personas and compete for attention on early proto-algorithmic platforms. Their approach now underpins the content creator and influencer economies. OnlyFans, in her view, represents the logical outcome of these trends. Users already accept posting content and seeking attention as ordinary online behavior. OnlyFans allows them to earn money from that attention by making audiences feel seen and validating the fantasies they project.
The Next Frontier
Nelson identifies two main trends. The first is the growth of parasocial intimacy and the normalization of paying individuals for online attention, a practice that was once limited to sex work. The second is the design of AI chatbots. Their engagement often appears sycophantic, and people have reported falling in love with chatbots and having sexual relationships with them. Nelson says chatbots are designed to keep users engaged longer, to make them feel validated, and to reinforce their self-image. She notes that cam models do the same. For this reason, she considers the intersection of AI and pornography the next frontier.
Conclusion
Nelson concludes that online pornography reveals how the internet functions. Her investigation led her to conclude that the online pornography industry is not primarily about sex. It reflects the incentives that keep people online. She describes viewing algorithmically engineered content in isolation as a metaphor for the relationship between people and their devices. People pick up their phones to soothe themselves and seek gratification, alone. She calls this the "masturbatory business model" of the internet.
Introduction
Nelson introduces the industry's scale and her six-year investigation into who profits from porn.
- Porn industry is worth tens of billions of dollars
- Some statistics suggest about 10% of internet traffic at peak times is porn
- Porn barons like Hugh Hefner and Larry Flynt are long gone
- Guest is Patricia Nelson, Financial Times reporter and author of Guilty Pleasure
- Investigation began in 2019 when the UK tried to introduce age verification
Origins of the Investigation
The investigation started with MindGeek, which owned Pornhub and YouPorn, and revealed heavy debt financing and a secret owner.
- MindGeek owned Pornhub, YouPorn and other tube sites
- Almost no public information existed about the company's ownership or profits
- The company was pumped full of debt by major Wall Street institutional investors
- The company was secretly taken over by a former Goldman Sachs banker few knew existed
- Trade journalists accused Nelson of being a conspiracy theorist
The Golden Age of Porn
Nelson describes the 1970s–1990s golden age of porn centered in the San Fernando Valley, its Hollywood-like production, and the impact of VHS and DVD.
- The golden age refers to the 1970s–1980s, centered in the San Fernando Valley (nicknamed 'Silicon Valley' for silicone breasts)
- Film scholars compared porn of that era to musicals, with sex acts as song-and-dance numbers
- Followed the sexual revolution and the porno-chic era, when mainstream cinemas showed porn; Andy Warhol made a porn film
- VHS, then DVD and hotel sales made porn private and highly profitable
Fabian Tillman and the 2012 Las Vegas Conference
Online porn changed distribution, and German tech entrepreneur Fabian Tillman's 2012 Las Vegas appearance marked a turning point.
- Tube sites offered free porn, often using stolen studio content, which angered producers
- Nobody knew who controlled the tube sites
- At a 2012 industry conference in Las Vegas, the keynote was delayed by half an hour due to crowds
- Fabian Tillman owned Manwin, the company behind Pornhub and many tube sites
- Audience members hummed the Darth Vader theme as he took the stage in a grey hoodie
Financing and the Affiliate Model
Tillman defended his business by claiming legitimate Wall Street financing and an attention-economy model built on affiliate marketing.
- Rumors suggested his money came from the Mafia; he said it came from Wall Street
- Early backers reportedly included JP Morgan, Fortress Investment Group and Cornell University
- He pitched the deal as an attention business, not a porn business
- He built affiliate marketing software tracking where users clicked
- Studios paid tube sites a finder's fee, reportedly up to 50% of subscriptions
Affiliate Marketing Across the Internet
Affiliate marketing underpins the modern internet, from news sites to Amazon and OnlyFans.
- The BBC posts content on X, Instagram, TikTok and Facebook to attract attention
- Amazon grew large through its affiliate marketing program
- OnlyFans pays a 5% finder's fee on a referred creator's earnings in their first year
Sale of Manwin and the Rise of MindGeek
In 2013 Tillman was forced out amid tax issues and the company was sold to executives and an unnamed investor, then renamed MindGeek.
- In 2013 Tillman was arrested for tax evasion and lenders pushed him out
- Lenders sold their debt after their names became public
- Tillman announced a sale to executives Firas Antoon and David Tassillo and an investor
- The company was renamed MindGeek and became secretive; executives reportedly gave press quotes without evidence they existed
Uncovering the Secret Owner
Nelson traced MindGeek's offshore tax structure and identified a secret owner named Bernard Burgemar, whose real name was Bernd Bergmeier.
- Intellectual property for Pornhub sat with a subsidiary in Luxembourg, a low-tax jurisdiction
- Two-thirds of some subsidiaries were owned by an unnamed shareholder
- A source on the phone revealed the owner as Bernard Burgemar, with almost no online footprint
- Only one hit: a 10-year-old court case naming him as director of Red Tube
- Burgemar was a fake name; his real name was Bernd Bergmeier, a former Goldman Sachs banker from Vienna
Bergmeier's Strategy and Data Business
Bergmeier bought Red Tube and MindGeek shifted toward data-driven analytics, reducing transparency.
- Red Tube was bought around the time Tillman exited the company
- Red Tube founders needed to sell quickly after one fell in love with a Catholic woman
- Bergmeier had no porn industry experience and sought advice from rivals over lunch
- Banner ads declined due to ad blockers and smartphone use, so analytics became central
- MindGeek collected user data and traded it to build commodified online profiles
Data, Privacy and the Shift to Paid Porn
Data collection by MindGeek raised privacy concerns, with data-led creativity and a 'parasocial' shift toward paid intimacy.
- Pornhub had a leak linking sexual preferences and search histories to email addresses
- MindGeek pioneered data-led creativity, using click data to decide what content to produce
- Paid porn is returning with OnlyFans, bespoke content and parasocial intimacy
- Cam sites, dating since the mid-1990s, combined with OnlyFans' feed-style interaction
OnlyFans, AI and the Next Frontier
Nelson argues sex workers pioneered online personas and attention economics, which OnlyFans and AI chatbots now extend.
- Cam performers were early online personas competing for attention
- OnlyFans monetizes the influencer model by validating audiences
- Chatbots engage users sycophantically, mirroring cam model tactics
- Nelson sees the nexus of AI and pornography as the next frontier
Conclusion and Reflections
Nelson concludes porn reflects the internet's engagement-driven business model, which she calls the 'masturbatory business model'.
- Online porn is about the incentives keeping users online, not just sex
- Watching algorithmically engineered content in isolation mirrors phone use
- She calls this the 'masturbatory business model' of the internet
