~5m36:14
Vincent Lapierre

PARIS SACCAGÉ : L'IMMEUBLE DE L'ENFER

Jul 11, 2024

Read: ~6m · You save: 30 min

Paris saccagé : L'immeuble de l'enfer (Belleville squat report)

Published 11 July 2024

A reporter visited Belleville, in the 11th arrondissement of Paris, after an anonymous police source described a building next door as entirely squatted by 30 to 50 Tunisian migrants. The source said the occupation was causing problems in the neighborhood. The reporter later described the number as about fifty undocumented Tunisians. The account below summarizes interviews conducted on site. The claims were not independently verified.

The Building

  • Background: Residents and the caretaker said the building belonged to an elderly man who rented apartments to people in need out of charity. He gradually lost control of the building, and undocumented immigrants occupied all of its apartments.
  • Current ownership: After the owner died, his daughter inherited the building. She has tried to resolve the situation but cannot evict the occupants.
  • Entry: The caretaker said the main door had been broken open and the windows were always open.
  • Duration: The caretaker said the occupation had lasted at least six months.
  • Police presence: The caretaker said police came to the building daily, sometimes two or three times a day. A resident said three police cars had entered the building two days earlier.
  • Other buildings: A passerby said another building across the street was also squatted.

Reported Incidents

Residents, shopkeepers, and pedestrians described the following problems:

  • Theft: Residents reported pickpocketing, phone theft, and the theft of bicycles and scooters. A shopkeeper said thefts occur daily. Snatch-and-grab thefts of necklaces target elderly people and young women near the Saint-Joseph school, across from the building.
  • Robbery and extortion: A woman said local young people harass residents, rob them, and extort money.
  • Drug dealing and assaults: The anonymous police source reported drug dealing and assaults in the area. A resident said the Jaurès and Stalingrad areas had previously experienced drug dealing, crack use, and deaths.
  • Violence: A man who did not want to appear on camera said a man had been beaten with iron bars in the building's lobby.
  • Nighttime disturbances: A first-floor resident said the occupants shout, sleep during the day, and create disorder at night. He said he had seen people constantly entering and leaving the building.
  • Impact on business: A shopkeeper said elderly customers no longer visit the store. He said thieves often arrive in groups of eight to ten people. His shop employs security staff.
  • Personal experience: A woman said she had been robbed five times in one year because her phones were stolen. She attributed the thefts to Romanians.

Occupants' Statements

Several occupants agreed to speak briefly. They said they work in construction, painting, mechanics, delivery, and as Uber drivers. One said his daily construction wage is 45 euros. Another said he pays 15 euros per night to a man named Fathi Jelassi, whom he described as the building's owner. One occupant said he had lived in France for ten years. Another said he had been in France for six months. Several occupants said they have no housing and that no one provides it for them.

The occupants denied that fights occur in the building. One said there are "aggressive young people" nearby. Asked about the police, one said officers come every day. Several occupants asked not to be filmed. The conversation ended in a dispute, and the reporter left.

Residents' and Shopkeepers' Views

Views on the neighborhood varied:

  • A resident who has lived in Belleville for 70 years said the neighborhood is good and remains so.
  • A resident who has lived there for 17 years described a strong social mix and a long history of immigration. He said most residents are French and that the problems stem from social injustice, not immigration.
  • A former resident said he had never before been involved in an argument in his life. He said he feels safe in Paris and that the incidents he has experienced involved drunk people.
  • A resident said he no longer lives in Belleville. He said he had seen residents say they feel unsafe.
  • A resident blamed the police, the Paris city hall, and the mayor's office for failing to act. He said he had attended a property management meeting where officials indicated they did not know how to respond.
  • A passerby said the occupants are right to occupy the building.

Debate on Causes and Responses

The reporter and a participant in the discussion disagreed on several points:

  • Causes of crime: The participant said poverty is the main driver of assaults and theft. He said wealthy people do not commit such crimes. The reporter said that most crimes are committed by people in survival mode.
  • Policy: The participant said that increasing police presence and harsher sentences would increase hostility toward the justice system. He said that solving poverty would be sufficient. He said prison does not reduce reoffending.
  • Immigration: The participant said deportation orders are not enforced and that the Schengen system allows people to enter and remain without control. He said most people who arrive in France will do so regardless of policy, and the focus should be on their reception.
  • Insecurity in France: The participant said there is no more insecurity in France than in other countries. He cited Italy and Germany as countries with comparable or higher levels of insecurity, and said Japan has harassment problems.
  • Media: The participant said media coverage increases the perception of insecurity. He said that the reporter's videos and programs such as CNews contribute to racism. He said the National Rally (RN) is polling at 36 percent. He said the reporter's videos show a dramatic image of France.
  • Political statements: A resident urged voters to support Marine Le Pen. Another praised President Emmanuel Macron.

The reporter rejected the claim that he had staged the scenes. He said that a man in Pigalle had threatened him with a knife for 50 euros and that the man was intoxicated. He said he had also been threatened in Belleville.