~6m32:30Is This Economy as Awful as Voters Think? We Ask Our Expert.
Oct 21, 2026
Read: ~6m · You save: 27 min
Is This Economy as Awful as Voters Think? We Ask Our Expert.
Why do voters feel the economy is awful even as data shows strength? Ben Casselman breaks down inflation, rates, wages, and AI risk ahead of the midterms.
Ben Casselman, chief economics correspondent, discusses the latest economic data ahead of the midterm elections
October 21, 2026
The economy is the issue voters cite most often ahead of the midterm elections. President Trump has argued that voters are wrong to be frustrated about the cost of living. He has said the economy is the strongest in the country's history, that oil prices are much lower, that inflation is almost nonexistent, and that the government has collected trillions of dollars. He has also said that Americans have more jobs than ever before.
The latest batch of economic reports, released in the week before this discussion, provides what is likely the final major economic snapshot before the midterms. The reports include retail sales, weekly unemployment insurance claims, industrial production, and several inflation measures.
Chief economics correspondent Ben Casselman says the data shows real strengths alongside a clear weakness: affordability.
The Three Components of Affordability
Casselman identified three measures that together describe the cost of living for a typical American family:
- Inflation: the rise in prices for goods and services
- Interest rates: the cost of borrowing money
- Income: wages and the amount workers and families receive each month
Inflation
Inflation, measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI), reached 9% in 2022, its highest level in 40 years. By the time Trump took office in January 2025, inflation had fallen to about 3%. Most economists expected it to continue declining toward 2%, which is generally considered normal.
Instead, inflation stalled near 3% after the administration imposed tariffs, which are taxes on imported goods. Tariffs add to costs for businesses and consumers. Inflation did not rise sharply, but it did not improve.
The situation worsened after the United States went to war with Iran. Oil prices spiked after the Strait of Hormuz, a key shipping route for global oil, was shut down, and global oil supplies tightened. Gasoline reached 4.50 per gallon, and diesel prices hit record levels.
The effects extend beyond the gas pump:
- Heating oil prices were up 74% from a year earlier.
- Airfares rose sharply because fuel is a major cost for airlines.
- Diesel, which transports goods by truck and powers farm equipment, raises the cost of food and other products throughout the economy.
Inflation for September, reported the previous week, was 3.7%. Casselman noted that this is far below the 9% peak of 2022, but it moved in the opposite direction from the reduction Trump promised on the campaign trail.
Interest Rates
The Federal Reserve, the central bank, manages inflation mainly through interest rates. It raises rates to slow the economy when inflation is high and cuts rates when inflation eases.
As inflation fell, the Fed began cutting rates, which made borrowing easier for consumers and businesses. When inflation rose again, the Fed stopped cutting. In September, it raised rates for the first time in three years.
Higher rates increase the cost of credit card balances, auto loans, and business loans for equipment and factories.
Mortgage Rates and Housing
Mortgage rates are driven largely by the bond market, which responds to inflation. The average rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage was below 3% during the pandemic. It rose to between 6% and 7% in later years and began to decline early in 2026. Rising inflation then pushed rates back up. The rate on a 30-year mortgage is now about 7.5%.
Many prospective buyers who had saved for a down payment and expected lower rates now face higher monthly costs. Casselman said many younger Americans believe they will never be able to buy a home, and that interest rates are a major factor in that belief.
Wages
Wage growth has slowed significantly. Average wage growth was about 4% a year ago and is now 3%. Over the same period, inflation has risen from about 3% to about 4%. As a result, the real value of paychecks, meaning pay adjusted for inflation, is falling. By some measures, wages adjusted for inflation have not grown since Trump returned to office.
In the post-pandemic period, wages rose quickly alongside prices. That is not the case now.
Economic Strengths
Casselman described several areas of strength:
- Business investment and profits have been strong.
- Stock market indexes have reached record highs repeatedly.
- New business formation has increased.
- Consumer spending has remained solid. Retail sales were up more than 6% from a year earlier, faster than expected.
Dependence on AI Investment
Much of the business investment is tied to artificial intelligence (AI), particularly the construction of data centers and the power plants that supply them. Casselman said this concentration creates risk. If enthusiasm for AI declines, investment could fall, the stock market could drop, and construction and employment tied to data centers could decline. Such a sequence could lead to a recession.
Some data center companies have recently faltered. Casselman said no one is yet predicting that the AI market will burst, but the risk of a sharp pullback is a concern.
Labor Market
The unemployment rate was 4.2% in September. It has been at or below 4.5% for five consecutive years, the longest such period on record. The previous record ran through the 1960s.
Casselman described the labor market as a "low hire, low fire" market. Employers hire few new workers and lay off few existing ones. Workers have fewer opportunities to change jobs, and job changes are a common way to secure large raises. Fewer job changes contribute to slow wage growth.
Casselman said it is a bad time to look for work but not necessarily a bad time to hold a job. Being employed is better than being unemployed, but the current market does not deliver consistent gains in pay for most workers.
Why Consumer Spending Remains Strong
Economists have expected consumers to reduce spending because prices remain high. Casselman said that has not happened and that the reason is not fully understood. He identified two factors:
- Employment: Most people still have jobs, so most can continue spending even if they are concerned about the future.
- Stock market gains: A majority of Americans own stock, either directly or through 401(k) retirement plans. Stock wealth is concentrated among the wealthiest households, which hold most of the market's value. Their rising portfolios have given them confidence and financial flexibility to keep spending.
Generational Divide
Casselman said the economy is divided between groups that are doing well and groups that are struggling. He described the generational gap as one of the sharpest.
Baby boomers approaching retirement generally hold substantial home equity. Many have paid off their mortgages or locked in low rates. Many also have investment portfolios that have grown, savings that earn higher interest, and Social Security benefits, which are adjusted for inflation.
Casselman cautioned that many older Americans are struggling. However, in aggregate, older voters are doing relatively well and younger voters are not. He added that older voters are often the parents of younger voters, and many older voters say they worry about their children and grandchildren. That concern shapes their view of the economy even when their own finances are stable.
Perception and Political Messaging
Casselman compared the current situation with 2024. The Biden administration argued that the economy was strong despite high inflation. Voters did not accept that message. Casselman said wages had not kept pace with inflation during that period, and voters were unhappy about it.
He said the Trump administration is now making a similar argument: that the economy is strong and that inflation and gas prices are the main problems. Casselman said voters again do not accept that message. He also said voters are partly correct, because the cost of living remains a serious problem regardless of other economic indicators.
Presidential Responsibility
Casselman said presidents have limited control over the economy. Some problems, including the inflation issue and the low-hire, low-fire labor market, predate Trump's current term.
However, he said Trump adopted specific policies that directly raised prices: tariffs and the war with Iran. Casselman said the merits and trade-offs of those policies can be debated. He said there is no question that both raised prices at a time when Americans are highly focused on the cost of living.
Government Debt and Interest Costs
Higher interest rates affect the federal government as well as households. The government's borrowing costs have increased significantly while federal deficits remain large. The federal government now spends about $1 trillion a year on interest payments on its debt.
Casselman said these costs could limit future policy options, including:
- Responses to the economic effects of AI
- Funding for healthcare and childcare
- Future tax cuts under a Republican administration
The Midterm Elections
If Democrats win a large majority, as some polls suggest, and take control of both the House and the Senate, they would gain significant power to check Trump's agenda, Casselman said. He declined to predict which policies Democrats would pursue or where they would succeed in blocking the administration. He said a Democratic majority could still produce policies with a real effect on the economy.
Casselman also said many of the underlying problems are long-standing structural issues. He said he finds it difficult to imagine that Congress could resolve them within two years. Housing affordability, childcare costs, and wage growth are unlikely to change substantially in that period. High interest rates further constrain the federal government's ability to act.
Key Figures
| Indicator | Figure | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Peak inflation (CPI) | 9% | 2022, highest in 40 years |
| Inflation when Trump took office | About 3% | Expected to continue falling toward 2% |
| Inflation, September | 3.7% | Up from about 3% |
| Heating oil prices | Up 74% | Compared with a year earlier |
| 30-year mortgage rate | About 7.5% | Below 3% during the pandemic |
| Wage growth | 3% | Down from about 4% a year earlier |
| Retail sales | Up more than 6% | Compared with a year earlier |
| Unemployment rate | 4.2% | September; at or below 4.5% for five years |
| Federal interest costs | About $1 trillion a year | Annual spending on interest on the debt |
Conclusion
Casselman said the latest data is not only a snapshot of current conditions. He said the underlying pressures that many voters describe are likely to persist well beyond the November election.
Other News
- Campaign spending: On Tuesday, Trump announced that he would spend 300 million that Trump said his political operation has already spent. The midterm elections, two weeks away, are on track to become the most expensive in U.S. history.
- Democratic fundraising: The Democratic National Committee has faced financial difficulties. Michael Bloomberg, the billionaire former mayor of New York, announced that he would give roughly $80 million to Democrats.
- Yemen: The Houthis have besieged Taiz, one of Yemen's largest cities, cutting off access to food, water, and fuel. Officials warn of a potential humanitarian catastrophe. The siege is in its third week. It is part of a wider conflict between the Iran-backed Houthis and the Yemeni government, which is supported by Saudi Arabia. On Tuesday, the British government said it would send fighter jets to help Saudi Arabia defend cities and critical infrastructure against Houthi missile and drone attacks.
Introduction and the Economic Picture
Trump says voters are wrong to be frustrated about cost of living. Ben Casselman says the latest data shows real strengths but also a serious affordability problem.
- Election issue most people are concerned about is the economy.
- Trump claims the economy is the greatest in US history, with almost no inflation and more jobs than ever.
- Casselman's first claim is that the latest batch of reports (retail sales, unemployment claims, industrial production, inflation) is the last major check before the midterms.
- Affordability is the key weakness, measured through inflation, interest rates, and income.
Inflation
Inflation peaked at 9% in 2022, eased to about 3%, then stalled after tariffs and rose again following the Iran war and oil price spike.
- CPI inflation hit 9% in 2022, the highest in 40 years.
- By Trump's inauguration, inflation was around 3%, with economists expecting a drop toward 2%.
- Trump's tariffs, which are taxes on imported goods, stalled progress at about 3%.
- Trump's decision to go to war with Iran shut the Strait of Hormuz, spiking oil prices.
- US gas prices reached 4.50 per gallon, and diesel prices hit records.
- Heating oil prices are up 74% from a year ago; airfares are way up.
- September inflation was 3.7%, released last week.
Interest Rates and Housing
The Fed raised interest rates for the first time in three years, pushing mortgage rates back up near 7.5% and locking many would-be buyers out of housing.
- The Federal Reserve manages inflation mainly through interest rates.
- The Fed stopped cutting rates, then raised them in September for the first time in 3 years.
- Mortgage rates were below 3% for a 30-year fixed mortgage during the pandemic, rose to 6-7%, then hit about 7.5% again this year.
- High rates hurt credit card balances, auto loans, business borrowing, and home buying.
Wages and Income
Wages have slowed while inflation rose, so real paychecks are shrinking; by some measures, inflation-adjusted wages have not grown since Trump returned to office.
- Wage growth slowed from about 4% a year ago to 3% today.
- Inflation rose from about 3% to about 4% over the same period.
- By some measures, wages adjusted for inflation have not grown since Trump returned to office.
Business Strength and AI Risk
Business investment, profits, and stock prices are strong, but heavy reliance on AI spending creates a risk of recession if enthusiasm fades.
- Business investment and profits have been very strong; stock market is at record highs.
- Much of the spending is tied to AI, including data centers and power plants.
- Some data center companies have faltered recently, though no one predicts an AI bubble burst yet.
- A loss of AI enthusiasm could cause pullbacks in investment and stocks, potentially leading to recession.
Labor Market
Unemployment is low, at 4.2% in September and at or under 4.5% for five years, a record; but the labor market is stagnant with low hiring, low firing, and low turnover, limiting wage growth.
- Unemployment was 4.2% in September.
- It has been at or under 4.5% for five straight years, the longest ever, surpassing a 1960s period.
- Low hire, low fire labor market means little job switching, which limits raises.
Consumer Spending
Consumer spending remains solid despite high prices, supported by people keeping their jobs and by wealthy households benefiting from stock gains.
- Retail sales were up more than 6% from a year ago, faster than expected.
- Most people still have jobs, so they continue spending.
- Stock ownership is widespread, but the wealthiest hold most of the value and their portfolios drive spending.
Generational Divide
The economy is split by generation: older Americans with homes, savings, and Social Security are doing relatively well, while younger people struggle, and older voters worry about their children.
- Older Americans often have paid-off homes or low mortgage rates, savings earning higher interest, and Social Security indexed to inflation.
- Younger Americans face high housing costs, child care costs, and stagnant wages.
- Older voters are often parents worried about their children and grandchildren.
Perception vs. Reality
Casselman argues the Biden administration's message that the economy was good despite inflation failed with voters, and Trump is now making a similar argument that voters reject.
- Voters did not accept the Biden administration's claim that the economy was good despite high inflation.
- Trump ran on addressing inflation and affordability but now says the economy is good with only inflation and gas price problems.
- Voters are right that cost of living problems are real.
Presidential Responsibility
Presidents have limited control over the economy, but Trump's tariffs and the Iran war directly raised prices, while other problems predate him.
- Inflation and the low hire, low fire labor market predate Trump.
- Trump's signature policies, tariffs and the war with Iran, directly raised consumer prices.
- The war with Iran especially drove up prices.
Government Debt
Rising interest rates have pushed federal interest payments to about a trillion dollars a year, limiting government options on AI, healthcare, childcare, and tax cuts.
- Higher rates raise the government's borrowing costs on top of large deficits.
- The federal government spends about a trillion dollars a year on interest on the debt.
- This could limit responses to AI, healthcare and childcare affordability, and future tax cuts.
Midterms and the Outlook
A Democratic House and Senate could check Trump's policies and affect the economy, but long-standing structural issues would be hard to fix within a few years.
- A large blue wave that gives Democrats the House and Senate would let them check Trump's agenda.
- Long-standing issues like housing, child care, and wages would be hard to reverse in a couple of years.
- Casselman says the economic snapshot reflects an enduring picture that will likely last past the election.
Other News Headlines
A brief news roundup covers Trump's planned $100 million for Republicans, Bloomberg's roughly $80 million for Democrats, the Houthi siege of Taiz, and British jets sent to Saudi Arabia.
- Trump announced he would spend 300 million already spent.
- The midterms are on track to be the most expensive ever.
- Michael Bloomberg gave roughly $80 million to Democrats, helping the financially struggling DNC.
- The Houthis have besieged Taiz, cutting off food, water, and fuel, in its third week; a humanitarian catastrophe is feared.
- The UK said it would send fighter jets to help Saudi Arabia defend against Houthi attacks.