~4m48:35DMP #23 - The Secret to Mastering Qigong
Dec 8, 2023
Read: ~4m · You save: 45 min
The Secret to Mastering Qigong: Internal Movement, Chi Building, and Transmission
Why do some people learn Tai Chi and Qigong subtly while others cannot? The speaker explains Chi, nervous system attunement, and the secret of transmission from teacher
The internal arts, including Qigong and Tai Chi, differ from external martial arts in how practitioners develop movement. The speaker argues that building qi is the key factor that determines whether a student can acquire subtle internal skills. This article summarizes the speaker's explanation of internal movement, the role of qi, the mechanism of transmission between teacher and student, and the implications for teaching methods.
Internal Versus External Movement
The speaker divides practitioners of Tai Chi into two groups based on how they move:
- External movement: The body operates according to the skeletal system, leverage at the joints, and the contraction of muscles and tendons. The speaker describes this as normal body function. Practitioners in this group focus on developing strong legs, flexibility, hip rotation, and posture. The speaker states that most martial arts and movement arts remain at this level.
- Internal movement: The inside of the body moves more than the outside. Nervous system, connective tissue, and fascia expand, stretch, and mobilize. Pressure within the body's cavities produces movement, and the outer shape forms as a byproduct of this internal activity.
The speaker states that external movement forms shapes directly, whereas internal movement generates shapes as a result of internal conditions. He describes this difference as substantial. He also states that practitioners who move internally are statistically rare.
The speaker's view is that practitioners who train only external movement are doing Tai Chi incorrectly. This is his opinion.
The Role of Qi
The speaker holds that qi is a real form of energy that can be developed and built up in the body. He rejects the view that practitioners already possess sufficient energy and only need to locate it. He states that the body functions as a mechanism that produces qi inefficiently at baseline. Training improves the efficiency of this mechanism, so that the body produces higher levels of qi.
According to the speaker, qi performs the following functions:
- It activates the connective tissues. Without sufficient qi, the internal tissues remain passive and move only as a byproduct of muscle and bone activity.
- It increases the malleability of the nervous system and tissues. A practitioner with more qi can produce greater pressurization and expansion inside the body.
- It enables more efficient learning and teaching.
- It moves through the body. External movement mobilizes blood and lymph but does not mobilize qi effectively. Internal movement, which involves the stretching and pressurization of the connective "wet suit" of tissues, mobilizes qi throughout the body. The speaker compares this effect to squeezing toothpaste through a tube.
The speaker identifies the first stage of qi as the "fluid of the mind." He describes it as energy generated by the interaction between the mind and the inside of the body. He uses this stage to explain how internal movement begins.
Stages of Developing Internal Movement
The speaker describes the following prerequisites for internal movement:
- Opening the body to create space. This stretches the small fibers of the connective tissue network.
- Bringing the mind inside so that awareness interacts with the tissues and wakes them.
- Changing the function of the nervous system so that it interacts more fully with the internal tissues.
- Developing qi, which makes the internal tissues malleable enough to move.
The speaker states that internal movement initially requires considerable effort. Practitioners may experience pulling, bruising, and aching as passive internal fibers become active. Once these fibers activate, a stretch travels through the body and generates force, which then becomes the mechanism for mobilizing qi.
Teaching Internal Movement
The speaker identifies the explanation of internal movement as a central teaching difficulty. He states that internal movements cannot be expressed through verbal instruction or visual demonstration because they vary between individuals and involve complex, intricate sequences of expansion, contraction, and pressurization. Teachers themselves often cannot identify exactly what occurs internally; they can only sense that movement occurs.
The speaker describes the following consequences:
- Teaching external movement is easier. Students can copy shapes and follow instructions, such as practicing a form three to six times daily. The speaker states that this method does not produce internal movement.
- Halfway methods exist. Some lineages teach rebounding jin, in which force travels through the body in a linear path and returns from the ground. The speaker describes this as half internal and half external. He states that he teaches this method because it helps beginners, but it does not represent full internal movement.
- Students may imitate external results. The speaker has observed lineages in which students copy the outward shapes of internal movement without developing the internal conditions. He describes this as "tail wagging the dog."
Nervous System Attunement
The speaker uses the interaction between animals to explain how internal states transfer between individuals. He states that animals communicate largely through nervous system attunement rather than complex language. When one animal meets another, its nervous system adjusts to harmonize with the other animal's state, and it feels internally what the other animal experiences.
The speaker states that humans use the same mechanism. Sensitive individuals, meditators, and people with highly strung nervous systems often pick up the emotional or physical states of others. Therapists and body workers who work with others continually may develop this ability gradually.
The speaker describes how intellectual processing reduces this capacity. People who rely on language and reasoning to understand others gradually lose the ability to sense others' states directly. The speaker reports that he experienced this loss in childhood, when he was naturally sensitive, and regained the ability after moving to China. Limited language skills reduced his verbal communication, and his sensitivity to others' emotional and physical states returned.
The speaker links heightened attunement to early stress. Children who grow up in threatening environments may keep their nervous systems in a state of scanning for danger, which can later develop into intuitive or empathic sensitivity.
Transmission
The speaker defines transmission as the process by which a student's body replicates the internal skills of a teacher through nervous system attunement. He describes the mechanism as follows:
- The teacher's internal state activates the nervous system of a nearby student.
- The student's nervous system and tissues adjust to match the teacher's internal condition.
- The student reproduces the internal movement, provided the student has sufficient qi to sustain the change.
Transmission requires physical proximity. The speaker states that a teacher with internal skill cannot transmit those skills through video or the spoken word. The student must be in the teacher's vicinity. He states that a teacher who practices only external movement cannot transmit internal skill, and students of such teachers may as well learn online.
The speaker identifies the following methods of transmission:
- Push hands
- Physical contact, such as placing hands on a student
- Training within the teacher's field or within a group, where students mirror one another and the teacher's internal condition spreads through the group
- Meditation, in which a teacher's stabilized mind can influence the student's mind
- Experiences of altered states, such as a blissful state, that students report after being near a teacher
The speaker states that some teachers radiate sufficient qi to activate the nervous systems of nearby people. He describes teachers whose qi field is strong enough that students feel internal changes only while in that teacher's presence. When students return home, they often cannot replicate the experience because they lack sufficient qi to sustain it. The speaker reports that this pattern can create dependence on the teacher and reduce the student's autonomy.
Ritual and Historical Practice
The speaker states that some traditional arts used ritual to increase attunement between teacher and student. He cites the bai shi ceremony, which he describes as originally a harmonization ceremony that brought the disciple into sync with the teacher to make transmission more efficient. He states that the ceremony is now primarily political.
The speaker also describes teachers who controlled transmission deliberately. Such teachers suppressed the mobilization of their internal bodies when they did not want a particular person to learn, and allowed mobilization when they chose to teach that person.
The speaker describes a teacher who taught general classes by sitting in a chair and let students practice while he watched. The speaker states that the teacher avoided moving internally in these settings to prevent unintended transmission. Students admitted to the inner circle received extensive contact and demonstration.
Reasons for Teaching Method
The speaker describes his own teaching approach:
- He teaches external mechanics first, including body movement and limb placement.
- He teaches halfway methods, such as rebounding jin and the development of the dantian cavity and channel opening.
- He does not teach subtle internal mechanisms through verbal or video instruction. He states that these require transmission.
- He practices alongside students, including qi-building exercises, to increase the likelihood that their bodies will replicate his internal state.
- He prioritizes qi-building exercises, including early periods of several months spent building qi before advanced training.
The speaker states that his students may find this approach unusual. He describes the early phase of his teaching as focused on building qi, which may appear to students as a departure from the art's curriculum.
The speaker further states that a teacher's qi level determines the reach of their influence. Students positioned far from a low-level teacher receive little transmission, whereas students close to the teacher receive more.
The speaker argues that the amount of qi a student builds determines how well the student sustains transmitted skills after leaving the teacher's presence. He states that higher qi reduces dependence on the teacher and increases autonomy.
Interpretation of Traditional Training Stories
The speaker interprets traditional accounts of long initial training periods, such as Circle walking, standing practice, or meditation before learning forms, as methods of qi building. He states that these practices build qi only when practitioners understand the process. Without this understanding, the same exercises produce stiffness and alignment without internal development.
According to the speaker, traditional teachers used this period to prepare students so that transmission could occur. When the student reached the required level, the teacher could transmit correct internal methods, physical instructions, and alignments. The speaker states that texts and classical writings then served to confirm the student's internal experiences.
Teacher Practice
The speaker states that a teacher must continue practicing. He describes the following reasons:
- A teacher who no longer practices cannot increase the quality of their own body, so students cannot reach the level required to replicate the teacher's internal state.
- Students require a teacher with sufficient internal skill to develop self-sustaining qi and eventually surpass the teacher.
The speaker concludes that the development of qi in both teacher and student drives the growth of an art and its transmission to future generations.
Summary of Claims
| Claim | Speaker's Position |
|---|---|
| Qi is a real energy that can be developed | Yes; the body must be trained to produce it efficiently |
| Internal movement is rare | Statistically uncommon |
| External-only training produces internal movement | No |
| Subtle internal skills can be taught by video or words | No; they require transmission through physical proximity |
| Higher qi increases transmission reach and sustainability | Yes |
| Teachers must practice to maintain transmission quality | Yes |
Internal vs External Movement
Internal movement is driven from inside the body by the nervous system and connective tissue, while external movement relies on skeletal leverage and muscle contraction.
- External movement: body operates through skeletal system, leverage at joints, and muscle contraction.
- Internal movement: pressurized, expansive movement of fascia, nervous system, and tissues shapes the outside body as a byproduct.
- Most Tai Chi practitioners are external; the internal camp is rare.
- Waking the internal body involves opening the body, bringing the mind inside, changing nervous system function, and building Chi.
The Role of Chi
Chi is a developable energy, and building it improves the efficiency of the body's mechanism; internal movement requires volume of Chi to mobilize tissues.
- Chi is not automatically present at full efficiency; it must be built through practice.
- Chi acts as the fluid of the mind, making internal tissues malleable and able to move.
- Without enough Chi, the elastic tissues do not move much; with more Chi, the inside of the body pressurizes and expands.
- Chi moves energy through the body like squeezing toothpaste, while external movement mostly moves blood and lymph.
Difficulty of Teaching Internal Arts
Internal skills are hard to teach verbally, so halfway methods like rebounding Jin are used, but full internal skill requires transmission from a teacher.
- Internal movements are difficult to explain and not uniform between students.
- Rebounding Jin is a halfway house between external and internal movement, used in lineages such as Jiang Manjin lineage (as referenced).
- Teaching purely externally is easier because students can copy shapes, but this does not produce internal movement.
- Teachers with high internal skill often have only one or two students close to their level.
Nervous System Attunement and Animal Communication
Animals and humans communicate through nervous system attunement, so a student's nervous system can harmonize with the teacher's and feel what the teacher feels.
- Two dogs communicate through nervous system attunement, not complex language.
- Humans attune nervous systems similarly, especially empaths, therapists, and body workers.
- Childhood stress can make the nervous system stay attuned to danger, leading to intuitive or empathic abilities.
- The speaker lost this sensitivity as a child and regained it after moving to China, when limited language skills reduced verbal intellect.
Transmission and Teacher Field
Transmission occurs when a student's body replicates the teacher's internal state in close physical proximity, and its stability depends on the student's Chi level.
- Transmission is nervous system to nervous system, not mind to mind in a mystical sense.
- Online learning can teach external movements but cannot fully transmit internal skills, which require being in the teacher's vicinity.
- Some teachers radiate enough Chi that students feel internal changes only within their field; once they leave, students cannot replicate the state.
- Dependence on the teacher can arise when students cannot sustain transmitted states without the teacher present.
Teaching Method and Building Chi
The speaker's teaching method: teach external forms, half-way methods, then build Chi with students through long Chi-building periods, so subtle internal skills can be transmitted.
- Teach external mechanics first, then halfway methods like rebounding Jin and developing the dantian cavity.
- Build Chi with students for months (for example, three or four months) before teaching advanced internal skills.
- Traditional practices such as standing, Circle walking, and meditation build Chi when understood correctly.
- Teachers should remain practitioners; a teacher who no longer practices limits students' ability to transmit and replicate skills.
- Students should build Chi on their own through foundational practices, even when studying online.
Traditional Ceremony and Controlled Transmission
Traditional bai shi ceremonies once harmonized student and teacher, and some teachers controlled transmission by choosing when to mobilize internally.
- Bai shi was originally a harmonization ceremony to bring student and teacher into sync for transmission.
- Some teachers switch off their internal movement when people they do not want to teach are present.
- Teachers allow internal mobilization for students they trust, letting those students emulate them.
- Students in the inner door are touched and guided, while outer-door students watch from afar.