~7m55:29Neville Goddard and His Discovery of the God Within with Mitch Horowitz (4K Reboot)
Jul 9, 2026
Read: ~7m · You save: 48 min
Neville Goddard and His Discovery of the God Within with Mitch Horowitz
Mitch Horowitz unpacks Neville Goddard's radical teaching that imagination is God, his mysterious teacher Abdullah, Castaneda link, and whether his methods truly work.
A conversation between Jeffrey Mishlove and Mitch Horowitz
Introduction
Psychologist Jeffrey Mishlove interviewed Mitch Horowitz, editor of The Ideal Realized: Practical Instructions from Neville Goddard and author of Magician of the Beautiful, Introduction to Neville Goddard, The Seeker's Guide to the Secret Teachings of All Ages, The Awakened Mind: How Thoughts Become Reality, and Occult America: The Secret History of How Mysticism Shaped Our Nation. The discussion covered Neville Goddard's core teaching, his methods, his relationships with other figures, his biography, and his legacy within the New Thought tradition.
Neville Goddard's Core Teaching
Horowitz described Goddard's central claim as the assertion that imagination is God, the creative power of life. According to Horowitz, Goddard taught that references to Christ, God, or the creator in scripture symbolically refer to the individual's own imagination. Goddard presented this idea literally. He held that every experience is a projection of the individual's emotionalized thought patterns.
Goddard's position was absolute. He did not qualify the claim that every relationship and every occurrence in a person's life is self-created. Horowitz characterized this as an extreme form of self-responsibility.
Horowitz acknowledged the difficulty of this position. He noted that people experience physical laws and forces, such as pain when a toe is stubbed or the mass of another person. Horowitz also cited Einstein's work to observe that linear time is not absolute, while maintaining that it remains a practical organizing structure. He stated that he agreed with Goddard that mind is ultimate reality, while acknowledging the material conditions of daily life.
Horowitz said Goddard's teaching presents a cycle in which the individual, who is the creator, has fallen asleep to this nature. The individual gradually realizes the creative faculties of the mind and eventually comes to understand the divine nature of his or her own being.
Goddard's Method
Goddard's method used affirmations combined with emotional engagement. Horowitz explained that Goddard's principle was that "an assumption, though false, if persisted in, eventually hardens into fact."
The procedure is as follows:
- Identify a desired outcome.
- Enter a state of physical stillness. This may be a meditative state or the hypnagogic state, the relaxed condition just before sleep.
- Mentally run through a scene in which the desired circumstance exists.
- Experience the scene from within rather than watching it as an external image. Goddard's example was: "If I wish to climb a ladder, I don't see myself climbing a ladder. I climb. I feel the rungs of the ladder in my hands."
- Continue the scene for as long as it feels natural.
- Allow sleep to follow, if possible.
Goddard practiced the method at 3:00 in the afternoon, after lunch, and not only at night. Horowitz noted that Goddard was not ascetic and drank wine with lunch. Goddard reportedly said, "Smoking, I never got. Drinking, that I got."
Goddard held that results may require a period of gestation. In his later career, he discussed gestation periods more often, comparing them to the development periods of human beings, horses, chickens, and goats. Horowitz said he had experimented with the method for most of his adult life.
Goddard challenged listeners to test the method and to "prove me wrong."
Goddard and Israel Regardie
Israel Regardie, a secretary to Aleister Crowley and a writer on the Order of the Golden Dawn, admired Goddard. In 1946, Regardie published The Romance of Metaphysics, a journalistic account of New Thought schools, including Christian Science and mind-creativity schools. Regardie devoted a long chapter to Goddard. He judged Goddard's system to be among the most effective and persuasive of the magical systems he knew.
Regardie also raised a criticism. Goddard was a trained actor and dancer who had come to New York City from Barbados at age 17 to study theater. He appeared in silent films and on the Broadway stage. Regardie argued that Goddard may not have recognized how difficult it is for an ordinary person to enter a persuasive emotional state. In Regardie's view, the system may require more training than Goddard had provided.
Horowitz said he took this criticism seriously. He addressed it in The Ideal Realized by compiling the practical methods Goddard described across his career. These ranged from At Your Command (1938) to lectures delivered months before Goddard's death in 1972. Horowitz also added his own observations.
Horowitz identified a limitation in New Thought more broadly. Individuals in profound grief, duress, or addiction may be unable to enter a feeling state at will. He distinguished between thought and emotion, which operate on different tracks. He quoted a teacher's statement that pitting thought against emotion is like pitting steam power against nuclear power. Horowitz argued that, in periods of suffering, additional help may be needed, or the individual may need to test whether creation is possible without a feeling state. Without such testing, he warned, these philosophies become stagnant.
Horowitz's Assessment of New Thought
Horowitz stated that he holds a firm belief that the mind has causative properties. He cited testimony from seekers, quantum theory, psychical research, neuroplasticity, relativity, string theory, and placebo research as sources of support. He said he uses the term "select" rather than "manifest."
Horowitz argued that New Thought has not matured since the death of William James in 1910. In his view, the movement has popularized itself through works such as The Power of Positive Thinking and The Secret more successfully than it has refined its philosophy. He said each generation must refine a practical philosophy. He also stated that New Thought needs a theology of suffering that addresses physical decline and material hardship, including end-of-life issues, pandemics, and chronic pain.
Goddard's Biography
Connection to Carlos Castaneda
Horowitz described a connection between Goddard and Carlos Castaneda. Margaret Runyan, who later married Castaneda briefly, had studied with Goddard in the 1950s and early 1960s. In her memoirs, she recounted meeting Castaneda, a stocky Latin art student at UCLA, at a friend's house. She gave him a copy of Goddard's short book The Search with her name and phone number inside. The two became lovers and then married.
According to Runyan, Castaneda showed little more than polite interest in Goddard's teachings. He became engaged when she described Goddard's background, specifically a teacher named Abdullah. Horowitz stated that Castaneda's books later became bestsellers. These books described his training under a Native American shaman, Don Juan. Horowitz noted that critics have questioned whether Castaneda's accounts were fabricated. He said Don Juan may have been a composite or a device. Horowitz stated that Runyan's account suggests Castaneda may have drawn inspiration from Goddard's backstory. Horowitz noted that he infers this from her account.
Abdullah
Goddard described Abdullah as a turbaned, mysterious teacher of Jewish descent who lived in New York City in the early 1930s. Goddard reported that Abdullah taught him number symbolism, Kabbalah, and the symbolic meaning of scripture.
Goddard stated that a Catholic priest, a friend, urged him to meet Abdullah. Goddard was hesitant because he held the priest in low regard. The priest had inherited money and squandered it on unwise investments. Goddard attended a lecture in 1933. Abdullah said to him, "Neville, you're 6 months late. The brothers told me you were coming and you're 6 months late." Goddard replied, "I am 6 months late. I had never seen this man before."
Goddard placed Abdullah on West 72nd Street on the Upper West Side of Manhattan and gave the building number. Horowitz visited the building and spoke with neighbors, who allowed him to look around. Horowitz has found no physical or empirical proof of Abdullah's existence. He noted that a newspaper reporter might have mentioned such a figure, but he has found no such reference.
Hypothesis: Arnold Josiah Ford
Horowitz proposed that Abdullah may have been Arnold Josiah Ford, a prominent figure in Marcus Garvey's organization. Horowitz stated that Ford wore a turban and fit the physical description of Abdullah in the few available photographs. Historians of the Ethiopianism movement have described Ford as having authentic knowledge of Hebrew and traditional Kabbalah. Ford identified as a rabbi, and Abdullah was sometimes described as an Ethiopian rabbi.
Ethiopianism, which Horowitz described as a precursor to Rastafarianism, held that Ethiopia was home to a lost tribe of Israel. It included mysticism, number symbolism, and a Kabbalah-derived outlook. It also included a mind-as-creator mysticism. Ethiopianism influenced Marcus Garvey. Horowitz discusses this in Occult America and One Simple Idea.
Horowitz stated that Ford later migrated to Ethiopia. After Haile Selassie came to power in the early 1930s, he offered land grants to African Americans willing to move to Ethiopia. Ford accepted and died soon after relocating.
Horowitz identified a timeline problem. Migration records show that Ford and Goddard were both in New York City in 1933 and could have met. Ford left New York City in late 1933 or early 1934. He therefore could not have studied with Goddard for the five years Goddard described. Horowitz stated that the hypothesis cannot be confirmed and remains one possible explanation.
Goddard's Military Service and Records
Goddard said he was drafted into the Army during the Second World War, when he was in his late 30s. He had a young daughter, Victoria, and lived with his family in Greenwich Village. Goddard stated that he requested a discharge, was refused, and then received an honorable discharge after using his method.
Horowitz checked Army records and found that they matched Goddard's account logistically. Goddard was discharged in March 1943, about four months after his induction. The discharge stated that he was returning to a "vital civilian occupation." An Army public affairs officer told Horowitz that Goddard's records were destroyed in a fire at a record-keeping facility one year after Goddard's death.
Horowitz also cited a profile of Goddard published in The New Yorker in September 1943. The eight-page profile described Goddard's activities on the lecture circuit in New York City. Horowitz described it as one of the few profiles of an explicitly occult or esoteric living figure that the magazine has published.
Horowitz stated that the records and other accounts he examined supported Goddard's account of his life.
Death and Later Teachings
Goddard died in West Hollywood in 1972, at age 67. The official cause of death was reported as a heart attack. His body was returned to Barbados, his home island, and buried in the town of St. Michael.
Horowitz described Goddard as a relatively obscure figure during his lifetime and for many years afterward. Late in his life, Goddard's message moved toward a mystical vision. He described a rebirth from within his own skull, referring to Golgotha, the place of the skull. Horowitz noted that myths and parables contain similar accounts of a god reborn from another being's skull. Goddard described further mystical experiences that led him to a fuller understanding of himself as God the creator. Horowitz stated that Goddard presented this as a universal human destiny rather than a personal claim of grandeur.
According to Horowitz, a speaking agent advised Goddard to return to law-of-attraction material to keep his audience. Goddard reportedly replied, "Then I'll speak it to the bare walls." Goddard retained a smaller audience in his final years.
Horowitz said that in 2003, when he began studying Goddard, few people knew his name. By the time of the interview, Goddard's name yielded hundreds of thousands of search results. Authors such as Wayne Dyer and Rhonda Byrne had referenced him. Horowitz recalled that a librarian at a Christian Science library in Boston asked who Goddard was. Horowitz stated that Goddard's writings, lectures, and books are now widely available in print, digitally, and online. He predicted that Goddard may become the most widely read figure from the New Thought tradition, and that this would have been difficult to foresee 15 years earlier.
Goddard and Reverend Ike
Mishlove noted that Goddard was an influence on Reverend Ike, a preacher associated with the gospel of prosperity. Horowitz confirmed that Reverend Ike listened to Goddard's lectures, which circulated on audio cassette in the analog era. Reverend Ike was reading Goddard in the early 1970s, when few people knew Goddard's name.
Horowitz defended Reverend Ike against charges of exploitation and distaste for his emphasis on money. He recalled an appearance on The Phil Donahue Show. When Donahue asked whether God wanted Reverend Ike to have a Cadillac, Reverend Ike replied that God wanted him to have a limousine.
Horowitz identified two questions about the prosperity teaching:
- Does the method work? Horowitz stated that journalists and many academics have treated the answer as settled. He argued that they rarely examine the experiences of congregants, including why they remain involved and whether they receive something of value. He said individuals must answer this question for themselves rather than rely on reporters or professors of religion.
- Is the teaching distasteful? Horowitz argued that the emphasis on money is not inherently distasteful. He stated that many spiritual cultures treat material needs as incompatible with spiritual life, and that this attitude is mistaken. He cited a therapist who said that about 70 percent of the problems her clients raised concerned a lack of money. Horowitz stated that the separation of inner and outer, higher and lower, and material and nonmaterial is artificial. He said that a mature individual can determine what he or she needs, including money, and that others should not reinterpret those desires.
Horowitz said he admires New Thought teachers who meet people where they live and acknowledge everyday concerns.
Goddard on Circumstance and Renunciation
Mishlove noted that Goddard said each person would pursue this process from his or her own station in life. Horowitz stated that Goddard taught that individuals would experience all the things of "Caesar," meaning worldly life, in this incarnation or another. Goddard believed in recurrent incarnations until individuals reached self-awareness. Horowitz said he accepts this view but has not verified it. He argued that people should not dismiss material life because they have not experienced it.
Horowitz cited Hazrat Inayat Khan, a Sufi teacher who was asked in the early 20th century whether renouncing wealth was necessary for spiritual awareness. Khan responded by asking whether the student had wealth to renounce. Horowitz stated that talk of renouncing wealth or of transcending worldly life has little meaning unless a person is in a position to make that choice.
Serial Universe and Quantum Theory
Mishlove noted that Horowitz had described Goddard's concept of a "serial universe," in which the universe is born and reborn repeatedly, rather than existing as multiple universes simultaneously.
Horowitz stated that in the late 1940s, Goddard told a Los Angeles audience: "Someday, scientists will explain to us why a serial universe exists, but what we are concerned with right now is how to use that serial universe." Horowitz dated this remark to 1948. He noted that Goddard made the statement before quantum theory had become popular. He also stated that the many-worlds interpretation had probably not yet been proposed. Horowitz attributed it to physicist Hugh Everett, who proposed it several years later.
Horowitz said that, as a lay reader, he studied Schrödinger's cat thought experiment while writing One Simple Idea, a history of the positive mind movement. He stated that his understanding of quantum theory is consistent with Goddard's outlook. He said he expects the relationship between Goddard and quantum theory to contribute to Goddard's prominence among 20th-century New Thought figures.
Horowitz reiterated that individuals will experience materialism and physical death, and that a philosophy must allow them to navigate that reality.
Introduction to Goddard's Teaching
Horowitz introduces Goddard's teaching of absolute self-responsibility and imagination as God, which he finds both compelling and challenging.
- Goddard taught that everything experienced, including every relationship and occurrence, is self-created.
- Horowitz notes the difficulty of this view when confronted with physical laws, such as pain from stubbing a toe.
- Mishlove introduces Horowitz, editor of The Ideal Realized and author of Magician of the Beautiful, Introduction to Neville Goddard, The Seekers Guide to the Secret Teachings of All Ages, The Awakened Mind, and Occult America.
Discovering Neville Goddard
Horowitz was introduced to Goddard in 2003 through baseball pitcher Barry Zito, and was profoundly affected by Goddard's book Resurrection.
- In 2003, while interviewing Barry Zito for Science of Mind magazine, Zito asked Horowitz if he was into Neville.
- Horowitz bought Resurrection, Goddard's last book, published in 1966; Goddard died about six years later.
- Goddard's core teaching: imagination is God the Creator, and scriptural references to Christ or God symbolize one's own imagination.
- Goddard wrote about 10 books and delivered hundreds of lectures, restating the same core theme.
- Horowitz compares Goddard's freshness of restatement to Emerson and Krishnamurti.
- Horowitz has a tattoo of Goddard with the phrase 'live from the end', designed by artist Tim Boda.
Castaneda Connection and the Abdullah Mystery
Goddard's possible link to Carlos Castaneda runs through Margaret Runyan, and Goddard's account of his teacher Abdullah.
- Margaret Runyan, Castaneda's wife briefly, was a student of Goddard in the 1950s and early 1960s.
- Runyan gave Castaneda a Goddard book called The Search, with her name and phone number inside.
- Goddard said his teacher Abdullah was a turbaned, mysterious black Jewish man of Ethiopian birth living in New York City in the early 1930s, who taught number symbolism, Kabbalah, and the symbolical meaning of scripture.
- Abdullah reportedly told Goddard, 'You're 6 months late. I've been expecting you.' Goddard met him through a Catholic priest friend in 1933.
- Goddard described Abdullah living on West 72nd Street in Manhattan; Horowitz could not find physical proof of Abdullah's existence.
- Horowitz hypothesizes Abdullah may have been Arnold Josiah Ford, a prominent figure in Marcus Garvey's organization linked to the Ethiopianism movement.
- Migration records show Ford and Goddard were in New York at the same time, but Ford left New York in late 1933 or early 1934, contradicting Goddard's claimed five years of study.
Method, Feeling States, and Physical Reality
Goddard's view of reality and his method of imaginal practice, including the advice to feel the scene and the gestation period.
- Goddard taught that a assumption, though false, if persisted in, eventually hardens into fact.
- Goddard's prescription: identify a desire, enter physical stillness or a hypnagogic state, and run a scene in which you experience yourself in it rather than watching it.
- Goddard's example: 'I climb. I feel the rungs of the ladder in my hands.'
- Goddard practiced this at 3:00 in the afternoon after lunch; he drank wine with lunch and said, 'Smoking, I never got. Drinking, that I got.'
- Goddard spoke of a gestation period, comparing it to human pregnancy of 9 months, horse 11 months, chick 30 days, and goat 3 to 4 months.
- Horowitz claims mind is ultimate reality yet acknowledges linear time and physical laws, citing Einstein's relativity regarding time slowing at light speed or in extreme gravity.
Regardie's Critique and The Ideal Realized
Israel Regardie's 1946 book The Romance of Metaphysics praised Goddard but criticized that his method required more training than most people possess.
- Israel Regardie, secretary to Aleister Crowley and writer on the Golden Dawn, wrote The Romance of Metaphysics in 1946.
- Regardie considered Goddard's system among the most effective and persuasive magical systems he knew.
- Regardie's criticism: Goddard was a trained actor and dancer who had come to New York from Barbados at age 17 to study theater, and may not have realized the everyday person needs more training to enter an emotional state.
- Goddard challenged people: 'Go home tonight. Prove me wrong.'
- Horowitz's book The Ideal Realized collects practical methods from Goddard's career, from At Your Command (1938) to lectures shortly before his death in 1972.
- Horowitz argues that mind and emotions run on different tracks and that a vow not to get angry can fail when emotions take over.
Maturing New Thought
Horowitz defends the practical value of New Thought while calling for its maturation, and reflects on the link between money, practice, and spiritual life.
- Horowitz feels absolutely certain that minds have causative properties and prefers the term 'select' to 'manifest'.
- He cites quantum theory, psychical research, neuroplasticity, relativity, string theory, and placebo research as supporting mind's causal power.
- Horowitz says William James died in 1910, after which New Thought has not matured, relying on books like The Power of Positive Thinking and The Secret.
- Horowitz argues New Thought needs a theology of suffering that addresses material decline and physical demise.
- He says it falls to each generation to refine a practical philosophy, noting religions like Catholicism and Judaism have changed over time.
Goddard's Life, Death, and Legacy
Goddard's life, army service, death, and the posthumous growth of his reputation.
- Goddard was drafted into the army during the Second World War in his late 30s, leaving a young daughter named Victoria in Greenwich Village.
- Army records show he was discharged in March 1943, to return to a 'vital civilian occupation'; his records were destroyed in a fire about a year after his 1972 death.
- The New Yorker ran an eight-page profile of Goddard in September 1943.
- Goddard died in West Hollywood in 1972 at about age 67; the official cause was reported as a heart attack, and he was buried in St. Michael, Barbados.
- Late in life Goddard described a rebirth from within his own skull, referencing Golgotha as the place of the skull, and told a speaking agent he would speak to 'the bare walls' rather than drop esoteric content.
- In 2003 few people knew Goddard, but today his popularity has grown, with references by Wayne Dyer and Rhonda Byrne.
Money, Prosperity, and Meeting People Where They Live
Horowitz discusses Reverend Ike's prosperity teaching, defends meeting people where they live, and relates Goddard's ideas about worldly experience.
- Reverend Ike read Goddard's audio lectures in the early 1970s.
- On the Phil Donahue show, when asked if God wants him to have a Cadillac, Reverend Ike replied God wants him to have a limousine.
- Horowitz argues critics rarely ask congregants about their experiences and why they keep returning.
- Horowitz says the distinction between inner and outer, material and non-material is artificial and that people may know what money they need.
- Goddard taught that one will experience all the things of Caesar in this or another incarnation, and believed in recurrent incarnations until self-awareness.
- Horowitz cites Hazrat Inayat Khan: 'Do you have wealth? How can you renounce what you don't already have?'
Serial Universe and Quantum Theory
Horowitz explains Goddard's views on a serial universe and quantum theory, and closes the discussion.
- Goddard said in Los Angeles around 1948: 'Someday scientists will explain to us why a serial universe exists, but what we are concerned with right now is how to use that serial universe.'
- Horowitz says Hugh Everett proposed the many-worlds theory several years later.
- Horowitz studied Schrodinger's cat to understand quantum theory and believes it comports with Goddard's outlook.
- Horowitz predicts Goddard will become the most widely read figure from the New Thought tradition.
- Mishlove closes the interview, thanking Horowitz and the viewers.