The Laptop for 71% of People: Google Book Review
Is this the ultimate laptop for Android users? Explore the Google Book's ecosystem, AI features, and hardware, but beware of its limitations!
A significant portion of the global smartphone market, estimated between 70% and 75%, utilizes Android devices. The Asus Google Book 14 represents Google's dedicated effort to create a laptop designed to seamlessly integrate with this user base, aiming for a fluid ecosystem where phone and laptop workflows, applications, and messages operate in unison. This approach contrasts with the experience of many Android users who have historically relied on third-party applications or workarounds to achieve similar integration with their laptops.
The Asus Google Book 14 is characterized by its thin and light design, an extensive port selection, and a high-quality screen. It also features the distinctive "glow bar" common to Google Books. Upon unboxing, the device immediately emphasizes its ecosystem integration. In a sleep mode, the laptop prompted pairing with a phone upon opening, facilitating an automated setup process via QR code scanning that configured Wi-Fi networks, passwords, and applications.
The operating system, Google Book OS, is built on the Android stack and presents an interface reminiscent of modern Android devices, featuring circular app icons, a bottom dock, and UI animations aligned with Google's Material Design language. While retaining some Chromebook characteristics, its visual interaction and user experience are more akin to an Android device. A key differentiator is its file system, which allows users to move files freely to their desktop or any desired location, a functionality described as essential for a "proper laptop" experience, distinguishing it from devices perceived as large tablets or phones.
The ecosystem concept extends to fluid interaction between the phone and laptop. Early in its launch, the device offers reasonable functionality, though some bugs are present. Users can initiate tasks on their phone and continue them on the laptop by clicking an icon. Phone applications can be streamed and run in a window on the laptop, controlled via the laptop's interface. Wireless access to phone storage allows for easy transfer of photos and files. Message notifications from the phone appear on the Google Book. However, phone call integration is currently absent, with no notifications or call handling capabilities on the laptop.
These ecosystem features necessitate the phone running Android 17, typically found on recent Pixel or Samsung devices. Other Android phones require an Over-The-Air (OTA) update to enable these functionalities.
Beyond ecosystem integration, the Google Book's design prioritizes Gemini AI. The system boots rapidly, reportedly in approximately 20 seconds, with "Gemini Intelligence" prominently displayed on the boot screen. The operating system is designed with AI at its core, integrating Gemini features directly. When prompted, Gemini identified "deep system-level Gemini intelligence" as the standout feature, powering capabilities like "Magic Pointer."
Magic Pointer allows users to wiggle the cursor or press the Google button to select items on screen for Gemini to interact with. This feature is described as more capable than "Circle to Search," enabling Gemini to perform actions on selected content, such as adding a date from an email to a calendar. Despite its utility, the activation method, involving wiggling the cursor, is considered unusual and potentially cumbersome, requiring cursor realignment after activation. This "wiggle" activation is heavily featured in marketing materials and even highlighted by Gemini itself when asked about the primary showcased feature.
Other AI functionalities include dictation with cleanup, similar to features on Google phones, and a widget creation tool that is considered more practical on a laptop's larger screen. Proactive assistance, a feature that utilizes on-screen information, notifications, location, and app data, is also present. While this feature is crucial for optimal AI performance, its data-gathering nature raises privacy concerns for users.
From a hardware perspective, the Asus Google Book 14 is praised for its build quality, exceeding expectations for its price point. It features a 120Hz OLED matte touchscreen, a responsive keyboard, and quick sleep/wake functionality. It offers features not present on the MacBook Air, such as USB-A and HDMI ports. The device is promised 10 years of software updates, though the long-term support is viewed with caution given Google's history of discontinuing products.
A primary concern regarding Google Books is software support, specifically its reliance on Android apps. While there was an expectation of developers creating full desktop-caliber applications, the current offerings are limited. Some apps are optimized for desktop with resizable windows, while others, like "Anti-gravity," are re-engineered for Google Book OS. However, the majority of applications do not fully leverage the laptop form factor.
The Google Book starts at 1,300. The hardware is considered excellent, but the functionality is seen as not fully justifying the cost, especially when compared to competitors like the MacBook Air, which offers robust desktop application support. At its current price, the Google Book is perceived as a niche product, particularly for users seeking Windows or macOS-caliber applications, which are not yet available. The inclusion of a Linux environment with terminal access caters to a specific user segment. For the broader Android user base, the device is described as a premium hardware offering for a cloud-centric Android experience, with the caveat that full-fledged desktop applications may be years away.
The Android Ecosystem Gap
The Google Book aims to bridge the gap between Android phones and laptops, creating a fluid ecosystem for the majority of smartphone users. Unlike previous solutions requiring third-party apps, this is Google's direct attempt at integration, offering a unified experience for apps, messages, and workflows.
- 70-75% of phones sold annually are Android.
- The Google Book is designed for Android users to create a phone-laptop ecosystem.
- Previous Android users relied on third-party apps or workarounds for phone-laptop interaction.
- This is Google's official attempt at an integrated Android ecosystem.
Asus Google Book 14: First Impressions and Setup
The Asus Google Book 14 is presented as a premium device, notable for its thinness, lightness, port selection, and screen quality. Its setup process is highlighted as exceptionally smooth, with automatic pairing and full setup via QR code, emphasizing immediate ecosystem integration upon unboxing.
- The Asus Google Book 14 is the thinnest and lightest model with the most ports.
- It features an 'awesome screen' and a distinctive 'glow bar'.
- The setup process is automated via QR code, pairing with the phone instantly.
- Passwords, Wi-Fi, and apps are set up automatically in sleep mode.
Google Book OS and File System
The Google Book OS offers an interface that strongly resembles Android, with circular app icons and a familiar UI, distinct from Chrome OS. A key improvement is its file system, allowing files to be managed logically, similar to a traditional laptop, which is presented as a significant step up from Chromebook limitations.
- The OS features circular app icons, a bottom dock, and modern Material Design.
- It feels more like an Android device than a Chromebook.
- The file system allows files to be moved freely, including to the desktop.
- This logical file management makes the laptop feel like a 'proper laptop'.
Ecosystem Features and Limitations
The ecosystem features allow for fluid interaction between the phone and laptop, including continuing workflows, opening phone apps in windows, wireless storage access, and message synchronization. However, phone call integration is currently missing, and these features require Android 17.
- Early ecosystem features allow continuing phone workflows on the laptop.
- Phone apps can be opened in windows and streamed to the laptop.
- Wireless access to phone storage for file transfer is available.
- Messages sync between phone and laptop.
- Phone call integration is currently missing.
- Features require Android 17; other phones need OTA updates.
Gemini AI Integration
The Google Book's second major selling point is Gemini AI, deeply integrated into the Google Book OS, which is built on the Android stack. The OS boots quickly and prominently displays Gemini. Key AI features include Magic Pointer for interacting with on-screen elements and improved dictation/widget creation tools.
- The laptop boots quickly (around 20 seconds) with Gemini branding.
- It runs Google Book OS, built on the Android stack, not Chrome OS.
- Gemini AI is built directly into the operating system.
- Magic Pointer allows Gemini to interact with selected on-screen content.
- Other AI features include improved dictation and widget creation.
Magic Pointer: A Bizarre AI Feature
Magic Pointer, activated by a cursor wiggle or Google button, allows Gemini to interact with screen content, similar to 'Circle to Search' but more capable. While useful for tasks like calendar integration, the 'wiggle' activation method is criticized as awkward and counterintuitive.
- Magic Pointer is a key marketing feature, activated by wiggling the cursor or pressing the Google button.
- It enables Gemini to interact with boxed or pointed-to elements on screen.
- Can be used for tasks like adding events to a calendar from an email.
- The 'wiggle' activation method is considered bizarre and impractical.
- Realigning the cursor after wiggling is awkward.
Proactive Assistance, Privacy, and Hardware Quality
Proactive Assistance uses screen content, notifications, and location data for AI-driven help, but raises privacy concerns due to Google's data collection. Despite these concerns, enabling it is crucial for the best AI performance. The hardware itself is praised for its build quality, 120Hz OLED matte touchscreen, responsive keyboard, and connectivity options, surpassing some MacBook Air features.
- Proactive Assistance uses screen info, notifications, and location for AI.
- Raises privacy concerns due to Google's extensive data collection.
- Hardware is well-built for the price, featuring a one-hand open design.
- 120Hz OLED matte touchscreen resists fingerprints.
- Keyboard is praised; device is thin, light, and has responsive sleep/wake.
- Includes USB-A, HDMI, and a glow bar (though its utility is questioned).
Software Support and App Limitations
The Google Book promises 10 years of software updates, but its long-term support is uncertain given Google's history of discontinuing products. The primary concern is the reliance on Android apps, with limited availability of desktop-optimized or re-engineered applications, making it feel niche despite its premium hardware.
- Advertised 10 years of software updates, but Google's product history raises doubts.
- The laptop primarily runs Android apps.
- Few apps are optimized for desktop or re-engineered for Google Book OS.
- 'Anti-gravity' is an example of a desktop-built app.
- Lack of full-fledged applications limits functionality.
- Competitors like MacBook Air offer better desktop app support.
Pricing, Value, and Niche Appeal
Priced from $900 to $1,300, the Google Book offers excellent hardware but struggles to justify its cost due to limited software functionality. It excels as a cloud-centric device but falls short as a full-fledged computer compared to competitors. While a Linux environment is available, the device remains niche for the average Android user seeking a complete laptop experience.
- Starts at 1,300.
- Premium hardware doesn't fully compensate for software limitations.
- Competitors offer better functionality for the price.
- Ideal for cloud-only or cloud-centric workflows.
- Feels niche due to a lack of real, full applications.
- A Linux environment is available for advanced users.
- Not a replacement for Windows or macOS caliber applications.
