~5m38:17Travel With Film: Are Airport Security X-Ray and CT Scanners Safe? The ULTIMATE Test!
Jan 18, 2024
Read: ~5m · You save: 33 min
Travel With Film: Are Airport Security X-Ray and CT Scanners Safe? The ULTIMATE Test!
Does airport X-ray and CT scanning really harm your film? A photographer tests different films, ISO levels and protective bags on real scanner passes.
Photographers who carry film through airports face two types of security equipment: conventional X-ray scanners and CT scanners. This test examined how each affects film, with and without protective bags, across several film types and sensitivities. The author used a reference roll kept at home for comparison.
Background
The author has experienced repeated problems with airport staff during hand checks. Other photographers reported similar experiences, including intimidation, fogged film, and visible X-ray lines. Before the test, the author lost 20 rolls of film, representing two days of commissioned documentary work, after they passed through a CT scanner at Geneva airport.
Test Setup
- Films purchased in Berlin: Cinestill 50 (50 ISO), CHS 100 (20 rolls), Portra 400, HP5 (400 ISO, black and white), and Rodinal developer. Powder fixer, stop bath, and wetting agent were also bought.
- Reference roll: One roll of each film type stayed at home, unexposed to security equipment.
- Development: Films were developed in Berlin. All scans used one fixed setting based on the reference film.
- Route: Berlin airport (multiple X-ray passes), Amsterdam (CT scanners), and return to Berlin (CT scanners).
- Passes: Films went through up to seven X-ray checks in Berlin and three CT scanners in total across the route.
Limitations
The author acknowledges that the test was not fully controlled:
- The intensity of the X-ray scanners could not be verified.
- Scanning speed varied.
- Films could not be laid in a perfectly flat row.
Three additional control tests were performed with smaller amounts of film.
Staff Interactions During Hand Checks
At Berlin airport, the author requested that a suitcase be scanned twice. The staff declined and asked for proof of the author's profession. The author showed a magazine containing her interview. The staff refused the request and stated that the author must achieve her goals by other methods.
On a later pass, the staff member who checked the suitcase was courteous and made no requests. Staff members at Berlin airport told the author that they had not previously seen film in protective bags. They were aware of the bags but had never inspected one.
X-Ray and CT Scanners: Key Differences
- X-ray scanners pass radiation from a single source through one plane, producing a flat image. Their radiation has a defined maximum power.
- CT scanners rotate the radiation source around the object to create a 3D image. The total radiation dose is much higher. The number of rotations can vary, and the security staff decide how many to perform.
Typical Damage
- X-ray scanners cause waves, fog, or both.
- CT scanners cause strong base fog but generally do not create waves. They produce soft vignettes, which affect images less than waves do.
Scanner data sheets state that the equipment is safe for film up to 1,600 ISO. The test results do not support this claim. Both 100 and 400 ISO films showed fog, and clear waves appeared on film from airport X-ray scans.
Results by Film Type
| Film | Exposure | Observed Effect | Condition After Exposure |
|---|---|---|---|
| ADOX HR50 (50 ISO, black and white) | 7 X-ray passes, 3 CT scans, no bag | Minimal base fog; faint vignettes | Fully printable |
| Cinestill 50S (50 ISO, color) | 3 CT scans, no bag | Slight green cast; less vivid colors | Correctable in post-production; smaller change in 35 mm |
| CHS 100 II (100 ISO) | 3 CT scans | Small base fog; reduced contrast | Correctable in printing |
| 200 ISO film (unnamed) | CT scanning, no bag | Visible contrast loss; strong blue-green cast | One CT pass with bag is acceptable; more passes cause severe green cast |
| 400 ISO black and white (HP5) | 1 CT pass | Serious base fog | Printable and scannable |
| Cinestill 400D (400 ISO, color) | 1 CT pass | Fog, green shift, intense grain | Damage is hard to ignore |
| Portra 400 (400 ISO, color) | X-ray at several airports | Measurable base fog; small green shift; no waves | Fully usable |
| 800 ISO film | 6 X-ray passes | Base fog and color shift starting at 3 passes; no waves | Completely usable |
| 800 ISO film | CT scanners | Destroyed from the first pass | Unusable |
| Delta 3200 (1,600 ISO) | 1 X-ray pass | Less base fog than expected; clear waves | Unusable |
| 3200 ISO | CT scanners, with or without bag | Severe damage from the first pass | Unusable |
Observations
- Black and white film suffers less than color film. Damage appears as more grain and less contrast, without a color shift.
- 35 mm film showed less change than 120 film because of the protection the canister provides. Even so, 35 mm film sustained significant damage from CT scanners.
- Shadows and underexposed frames showed the most damage. Frames exposed at minus one and minus two stops revealed more change than normally exposed frames.
- Repeated CT exposure increases damage. Each additional CT pass worsens contrast, grain, and color.
Protective Bags
Airport staff in Berlin stated that they increased scanner power to see through protective bags. The films then remained in the scanner longer than they otherwise would. CT scanners were unable to see through the bags.
The author measured base fog to estimate protection. Bags reduce exposure by 30 to 50 percent. No bag provides complete protection. Some radiation still reaches the film, but bags are better than no protection.
On 120 film, base fog was stronger on the outer layers than on the inner layers. The last frame on one roll had half the fog of the first frame.
Lead Containers
The author built containers from a medical X-ray lead apron. Each container had a stainless steel outer shell and an inner layer of lead rubber. The author flew to and from a destination, passing through scanners twice. Film inside the containers still showed damage. The author noted that the containers should not be made at home, especially in households with small children.
Safety of Airport Staff
The author questioned whether airport security staff are adequately protected from radiation. CT scanners have openings at both ends. In hospitals, staff leave the room during CT scans. The author stated that she hopes airport staff wear radiation badges to monitor their exposure.
Manufacturer Response
Together with Silvergrain Classics magazine, the author sent an official press inquiry to the scanner manufacturer SMITHS, approximately two months before the test was filmed. As of the time of the test, no reply had been received.
Conclusions
- CT scanners cause severe damage to film. The author advises avoiding them.
- Conventional X-ray scanners do not completely destroy film. The claim that they are safe up to 1,600 ISO does not hold under the test conditions.
- Black and white film tolerates X-ray exposure better than color film.
- Protective bags reduce damage by 30 to 50 percent.
- Lab technicians reported finding two to three X-ray-damaged films per week. Given the high volume of film processed, the author considers this number small and notes that most travelers are not affected.
- Film exposure in airports does not always cause visible damage. Waves appeared in only a small number of the author's rolls. The author estimates that the risk for an individual traveler is low, but not zero.
The author plans to publish a follow-up video covering strategies for requesting hand checks at airports and steps to take if film passes through a CT scanner.
Introduction and Motivation
Lina introduces her concern about airport security damaging her analog film after losing 20 rolls to a CT scanner at Geneva airport.
- Lina is an all-analog photographer who has had many stressful experiences flying with film.
- She lost 20 rolls, two full days of commissioned documentary work, after passing through the CT scanner at Geneva airport.
- Many followers reported intimidation by staff, fogged films and X-ray lines.
- Her test asks whether X-ray and CT scanners, with and without protective bags, really harm film or whether fears are exaggerated.
- The test is sponsored by FOTOIMPEX; sponsorship mention excluded from summary.
Preparing and Buying Film in Berlin
Lina buys a large amount of film at FOTOIMPEX in Berlin for the test, including color, black and white and 120 and 35mm formats.
- Purchases include Cinestill 50 (120 and 35mm), Portra 400, HP5 black and white, CHS 100 and Rodinal developer.
- She buys 20 rolls of each type and extra chemistry such as powder fixer, stop bath and wetting agent.
- The 120 CHS 100 film was freshly produced at the ADOX factory the day before.
- Her hands are bleeding and numb from rolling and winding films through the night.
Berlin Airport Security Passes
Lina passes through Berlin Airport security multiple times, with varying staff responses, to test X-ray exposure of her film bags.
- On the first pass, staff refused to hand-check or rescan her suitcase and questioned her right to demand it.
- Staff asked for proof of her job; she showed a magazine with her interview.
- She passed through security six times at Berlin Airport and at least seven checks total before Amsterdam.
- Staff said they had never seen a bag like hers before, but ran extra checks anyway.
- Staff reportedly saw film inside the bags on the X-ray.
Amsterdam Trip and Return to Berlin
Lina flies to Amsterdam, passes CT scanners, and returns to Berlin, noting that CT scans are slower, more energy-intensive and possibly more damaging.
- KLM lost her luggage at least three times during the trip.
- Her last check-in was in a different terminal, so she had to go back through checks.
- She was told CT scanners can barely see through bags, but X-ray staff claimed the opposite.
- She arrived back in Berlin at 11:00 p.m. after walking extensively that day.
Processing and Chemical Notes
Lina processes the film at home and reports on the developer's properties, then uses CT scan tests to confirm how severely the scanners damage film.
- Developer and fixer were used to process films, and the powder chemistry creates no dust and is safe to use.
- Repeated CT scan tests with no bag showed severe fog and loss of image when a single pass is used.
- The films were developed at a controlled temperature of 20°C.
Test Results by Film Type
Lina explains X-ray and CT scanner differences and reports on how different ISO films reacted to repeated scanner exposure.
- Standard X-ray scanners send radiation from one plane and create a flat image with a maximum power level.
- CT scanners rotate the source around the bag to create a 3D image, producing much higher radiation exposure.
- Scanner data sheets claim safety up to 1600 ISO, which Lina says is not true.
- 800 ISO film showed base fog and color shift after six X-ray passes but remained usable.
- Portra 400 showed increased base fog and a green color shift after X-ray passes.
- HP5 (400 ISO black and white) showed increased base fog but was still usable.
- Delta 3200 showed clear waves and became unusable after one pass.
- ADOX HR50 (50 ISO black and white) survived seven X-rays and three CT scans with minimal base fog.
- Cinestill 50S showed a slight green cast after three CT passes without a bag.
- CHS 100 II showed small base fog and loss of contrast after three CT scans.
- Cinestill 200 showed loss of contrast and blue-green cast after CT scans without a bag.
- 400 ISO color film was badly damaged by CT scanners: two passes destroyed the images.
- 3200 ISO film was destroyed by CT scans from the first pass, with or without a bag.
Protective Bags and Canisters
Protective bags reduce damage only partially, and 35mm canisters provide extra protection over 120 film.
- Airport staff said they increased scanner power to see through the bags, extending exposure time.
- CT scanners did not see through the bags.
- Protective bags reduce damage by 30 to 50% based on base fog measurements.
- 35mm canisters offer extra protection compared to 120 film.
- Base fog was stronger on the outside of 120 rolls than inside.
Lead Containers and Staff Safety
Lina tested lead-lined containers made from a medical X-ray apron but still found damage, and questions the safety of scanners for staff.
- The lead-rubber containers were built from a medical X-ray protection apron, which she advises not to attempt at home.
- Even with the lead containers, Portra 400 film was damaged after two passes.
- She questions whether security staff are safe because CT scanners have openings at both ends, unlike hospital CT rooms.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Lina concludes that CT scanners should be avoided, X-ray damage is variable, and black and white film is more resistant than color.
- CT scanners should be avoided at all costs according to Lina.
- Regular X-ray scanners may cause fog and waves; she had waves on about five rolls over her life.
- Black and white film suffers less damage than color film, mainly through more grain and less contrast.
- She will cover the best strategy for hand checks and what to do after a CT scan in her next video.