~1m1:22:23We Read What Therapists Are Being Taught Next Year and We’ve Got Bad News
Nov 16, 2026
Read: ~1m · You save: 81 min
We Read What Therapists Are Being Taught Next Year and We've Got Bad News
Hosts dissect why rage-bait content hooks us, how therapist accreditation really works, and Andrew Hartz's bold critique of the APA's politicized conferences.
Continuing Education Accreditation
Licensed mental health professionals in the United States must complete continuing education (CE) hours each year to keep their licenses. Nearly every state requires a set number of hours. Professionals such as therapists, psychiatrists, nurses, psychologists, social workers, and counselors all fall under these requirements.
Continuing education credits must come from accredited providers. Several professional bodies accredit CE content, including the NBCC (for counseling), NASW and ASWB (for social work), the APA, and the AMA. Hartz and Henderson described the process as burdensome. A CE talk requires:
- A proposal with references and learning objectives, each phrased in a specified way
- A review of the presenter's slides and required edits
- Compliance with rules, including a prohibition on promoting the presenter's practice, books, or programs
- Diversity statements and other documentation
- A post-session questionnaire on the quality of the work, which must contain specific elements
Hartz said that accreditors enforce these technicalities selectively. Talks they dislike receive closer scrutiny, while others pass without it. Hartz reported that two talks hosted by the Open Therapy Institute were rejected. Hartz said accreditation fees are high and that his organization pays an accreditation specialist to submit documentation, which he estimated at 12 documents and hundreds of pages for APA accreditation.
Hartz described the system as a mix of private and government roles. The state licensing requirement is public, but the accreditation that makes CE hours count comes from private organizations.
Online Anger and Emotional Response
Henderson said anger can feel good or bad depending on its context. Personal anger, such as learning that a partner has been unfaithful, is distressing. Anger at political opponents, by contrast, often comes with self-righteousness. It can make people feel good about themselves. People then share the content with friends, which creates a bond over a shared opponent. Henderson said this can feel good but is not necessarily healthy.
Hartz said the shared element drives the response. Watching a public figure attacked online is satisfying to many people, and Hartz said he also experiences this.
Henderson cited a study, conducted before Elon Musk acquired Twitter, that examined which features predicted virality. The study identified 15 "moral emotional" words. Each one included in a post was associated with a 20% increase in the likelihood of a retweet. Almost all of these words were negative, including attack, blame, bad, kill, hate, fight, and destroy. The only positive word, care, was often used in a negative sense.
Several participants compared this pattern with earlier media. Talk radio hosts and televised political debates have long used provocation. Participants argued that online content differs because the scrolling format bypasses deliberate choice. Henderson suggested that people do not decide in advance to consume outrage, and that fast scrolling reaches the impulsive part of the mind before the reflective part engages.
Participants offered several explanations for why anger attracts attention:
- Freud's model of innate sexual and aggressive drives, which they described as one partial fit
- The idea that people seek content that gives them permission to express aggression they already feel
- Moral outrage that externalizes judgment, which may spare people from turning judgment inward
Hartz also described an implicit comparison in which condemning others confirms one's own goodness. He cited a 2016 Hillary Clinton rally where the audience chanted "shame" as an example.
Advice on Political News Consumption
The discussion began with a listener question from Christine in Pasadena. She asked for ways to manage anxiety and worry about current politics, beyond deleting unread political fundraising emails, avoiding the news, and avoiding political conversations with friends.
Hartz recommended reducing exposure to political news and social media. He suggested that people limit social media checks to a set time each day and agree with family and peers not to discuss politics. Hartz said he knows people who have followed this approach successfully.
Henderson argued that anger drives repeated exposure and that people often believe they need to stay informed regardless of emotional cost. He pointed to the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. He said that people who read every update reported feeling obligated to stay current. Four years later, Henderson said, the reading had not changed their lives. Henderson said the goal should be clear: whether a person wants to be fully informed at any emotional cost, or informed and emotionally stable.
Henderson also said that political division reflects emotion regulation problems more than ideology. He said extremism builds on emotional dysregulation. He recommended identifying the specific emotion, such as threat, hurt, or feeling unsettled, and addressing it directly, without necessarily changing one's views or disengaging.
Henderson and Hartz agreed that the duration of brooding matters. Hartz said five minutes a day is short. Henderson said a therapist might allow 30 minutes to an hour, because people often need less time by the end of that period.
Hartz said most media is ideologically divided. Sources that present both sides of an issue and weigh evidence fairly are scarce. Hartz said people who want to understand events should consume balanced sources, while people who consume one-sided media are less likely to understand what is happening.
Division 39 of the American Psychological Association
Hartz and Colin Wright, an evolutionary biologist, co-wrote an op-ed published in The Wall Street Journal on October 20. The article focused on the APA's advisory board and a recent conference. Its headline was "The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association."
Hartz said he receives frequent emails about developments within the mental health field. He said people outside the profession do not understand the field's internal situation. He said the field has the same biases that higher education has. He described two types of evidence: statistics and personal accounts. He said statistics do not fully capture the situation, and that qualitative storytelling is needed.
Hartz cited these statistics:
- Psychology professors are liberal to conservative at a ratio of 17 to 1
- About 15% of therapists identify as socially conservative
Hartz described Division 39, the APA's Division of Psychoanalysis, as the clearest example. Its spring meeting is its annual conference. Hartz said the conference draws hundreds of attendees and includes 90 talks. He said the talks focus almost entirely on political themes and rarely address therapy, evidence, research, patience, the unconscious, transference, attachment, or ego.
Hartz said the 2027 call for papers lists topics including colonial domination, imperialism, proximity to whiteness, feminist studies, critical race theory, carcerality, and resistance. He said none of the psychoanalytic terms appear in the list.
Hartz described one talk, titled "Drag Desire and Queer Theory at Work in Psychoanalysis," whose description concluded with an announcement that a drag performance would take place. Hartz said the APA granted continuing education credit for this session, which he said raised questions about the standards applied to accreditation.
Hartz and Wright reviewed the program and categorized talks by topic. They reported that 20 of the 90 talks did not fit the identity politics category. Those 20 addressed neurodivergence, disability, or AI, and Hartz said these also related to political themes. Hartz said the program included no speakers identified as conservative, libertarian, heterodox, or moderate.
Hartz named Sophie Lewis, a keynote speaker. Lewis co-translated Communism for Kids and wrote Abolish the Family: A Manifesto for Care and Liberation, and spoke on family abolition.
Hartz said the problem extends beyond Division 39. He said other APA divisions and organizations outside the APA follow similar patterns. Hartz said the call for papers opens each year on Nakba Day, and that the conference's preoccupation with Israel and Palestine is the largest topic by a wide margin.
A listener asked whether this pattern follows the events of October 7, 2023. Hartz said the field has aligned with many causes over time, including transgender issues, Black Lives Matter, anti-colonial therapy, and queer therapy. He cited an inpatient residential program for people with schizophrenia that described queering its treatment unit on its website. Hartz said this is unethical.
Hartz said a Harvard-related example illustrated the broader trend. He cited testimony by university presidents, including Claudine Gay, regarding calls for genocide against nonprotected groups and microaggressions against protected groups, and said he had argued for years that such a double standard existed.
Hartz described these claims as difficult to believe until people see examples, and said that he cannot reference all examples in one article.
Timeline
Participants said the shift began around 2014, when many institutions changed. Hartz said the field had long had a leftward tilt, but that guardrails broke down during Obama's second term. He said people in small activist groups then gained control of many institutions.
Governance and Voting
Hartz cited an unverified figure that about 6,000 votes were cast in the APA's recent presidential election, from an organization with roughly 100,000 members. He said a small group could win control of the organization with about 3,000 votes.
Hartz attributed the situation to a lack of organized response. He said most psychologists disagree with the direction but disengage rather than build alternatives. He estimated that a majority of therapists hold moderate, center-left, or liberal views and oppose this direction, but do not support institutions that could reform the field.
Participants suggested reforms. Dean McKay proposed a minimum voter turnout requirement for member-led organizations. Participants said low turnout allows small groups to control leadership and committees, and that such bodies face little accountability.
Participants also discussed Robert Conquest's laws. Conquest held that any organization that is not explicitly conservative will become liberal over time. Participants said this creates a tension: an institution that protects itself from capture by being openly conservative may produce weaker work.
Therapist-Client Dynamics
Hartz said some therapists in the field advocate for approaches such as "queering" psychotherapy. He said he knows colleagues in couples therapy training programs whose students state that their goal is to "queer the relationship." Hartz said the clients are not told this in advance. Hartz said he is unaware of evidence that such approaches improve relationships, and he described efforts to undermine a couple's gender or sexual preferences as unethical.
Hartz said a therapist's biography may not reveal a feminist or radical orientation. He noted that fewer therapists list pronouns in their bios, which makes such orientations harder to detect.
Hartz described clinical settings where intake forms began with the question, "What are your pronouns?" He said some patients responded positively and others reacted negatively.
Hartz and Henderson discussed clients who self-censor. Henderson said clients who withhold important parts of their lives limit the effectiveness of therapy. Hartz said therapists should not be required to share a patient's political views. He said therapists should avoid derogatory comments about a patient's political, racial, or gender beliefs, and that patients should raise such concerns. He said a patient should leave if a therapist cannot respond to such concerns.
Hartz cited a practice he attributed to Division 39 advocates: raising race in the first session of every therapy relationship, including when both participants are white.
Hartz said most students and therapists have sufficient judgment to avoid such practices, but some do not, and that these practices damage relationships.
Gender Composition of the Profession
Hartz said psychology was majority male, at about 55%, into the 1970s. He said the field is now about 80% female. Hartz cited anecdotes of graduate programs with 50 students and one male.
Hartz referred to a talk by Joshua Aronson. Aronson described a climate in which derogatory comments about men are normalized in classrooms. Hartz said such climates cause students to lose confidence and leave. Hartz also said therapy is often framed in feminized terms, which may discourage men.
Helen Andrews wrote that many organizations showed dramatic changes in their approach to "wokeness" after women passed 50% to 51% of membership. Hartz said he did not know whether the APA or its divisions followed this pattern.
Hartz said psychiatry differs. Some psychiatrists choose the field deliberately, while others end up there after not matching into their preferred specialty. Hartz said that psychiatry is therefore less self-selected than clinical psychology.
Henderson said men show strong interest in personality, social, and evolutionary psychology. He said fields that become majority female often lose male interest, while fields coded as male tend to attract women.
Art and Politics
Henderson said most political division has a strong emotional component. He also raised whether all art is political, and whether political art tends to succeed. Participants discussed:
- The view that art cannot be political in a meaningful sense
- The argument that overtly political art, including Soviet art, often fails artistically
- Yukio Mishima's Sun and Steel and his tetralogy, beginning with Spring Snow, which participants described as strongly right-leaning and sophisticated
- Norman Mailer and John Cheever, whom participants discussed as authors whose work did not align neatly with conservative or liberal categories
Hartz defined heterodox thinking as forming opinions case by case rather than adopting a fixed set of positions.
Participants said conservative creators struggle to build institutions in film and the arts. Hartz said he considers a conservative film studio the wrong approach. He said the business model for art has also changed, with short-form video and Substack replacing traditional routes, and that heterodox writers are active in podcasts, Substack, and opinion writing.
Conclusion
The participants concluded that the issues they discussed are persistent. Hartz said the field will continue to produce examples, and the discussion will continue with the 2027 conference. The participants said they plan to address the question of "woke two" in a future episode.