~4m16:29
Sky News

Brexit's economic impact: What the data reveals | Ed Conway analysis

Read: ~4m · You save: 12 min

Economic Consequences of Brexit: What the Data Shows

What really happened to the UK economy after Brexit? We compare the dire forecasts with real data on GDP, trade, and migration.

The debate over the consequences of Brexit has been going on for a long time. Below, economic data is examined without political assessment: the 2016 forecasts, actual developments, methods for estimating the effect, and possible alternative explanations.

"Project Fear" Forecasts and Actual Results

Before the 2016 referendum, the UK Treasury forecast a severe recession in the event of a exit from the EU. Under the moderate shock scenario, GDP was expected to fall by 3.6%. Under a severe shock, the decline was estimated at roughly 5–6%.

Unemployment was forecast to rise by 1.6–2.4% in the shock scenario. House prices were projected to fall by 10–18%. The pound was estimated could fall by 12–15%.

The actual data for the two years after the vote differed from the forecasts:

IndicatorTreasury ForecastActual Change
GDPFall of 3.6% (moderate shock) and 5–6% (severe shock)Growth
UnemploymentRise of 1.6–2.4%Decline
House pricesFall of 10–18%Rise of 7%
Pound exchange rateFall of 12–15%Fall of 10%

The forecast for the pound's exchange rate turned out to be the closest to reality. The other forecasts diverged significantly from the facts.

Brexit Impact Estimates: Discrepancies

During the referendum period, a number of organizations forecast growth for the UK economy after Brexit. These included Oxford Economics, Open Europe, and Economists for Brexit. Almost all other economists, however, expected growth to decline.

The economic logic behind this forecast is that introducing trade barriers with the closest partner increases frictions and reduces economic growth. This logic formed the basis of most of the estimates.

Later estimates produce the following results:

  • The U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) estimates the effect at roughly 7%.
  • The UK Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) estimates the effect at roughly 4%. According to its representatives, this figure represents the average of a number of external forecasts.

The "Doppelganger" Method

Most estimates are based on the doppelganger method. The essence of the method is as follows. A group of economies is selected that developed similarly to the United Kingdom before 2016. Then their actual dynamics are compared with the dynamics of the United Kingdom after 2016.

Before 2016 the trajectories coincide. After the referendum they diverge. The size of the divergence is the estimate of the Brexit effect. This method is used for both GDP growth analysis and investment analysis. The divergence in investment is more pronounced. Part of the divergence, however, began before 2016.

The method has a weak point: it assumes that without Brexit the UK economy would have developed comparably to the selected countries. This assumption is debatable.

If we compare GDP per capita growth in the G7 countries (Japan, Germany, France, Italy, Canada and the United Kingdom), the UK is in the middle of the list. It outpaces France and Italy. The outlier is the United States, which showed exceptionally high growth in recent years. Excluding the US from the comparison group narrows the gap but does not eliminate it: without the US, the UK economy is below its possible level, yet this level is still higher than the actual one.

Three Questions of Causality

Assessing the effect of Brexit requires answering three questions.

1. Was the decline caused by Brexit or did it exist earlier?

The UK's share of global services exports has remained one of the highest since 2005. In goods exports, the country has consistently lost ground, with China in first place. This points to a structural decline in the volume of goods production and exports.

Nevertheless, trade data also indicate an effect of Brexit:

  • Until 2016, the growth of UK goods trade was relatively high among G7 countries.
  • After the referendum, the UK ranked last in the growth rate of goods production and exports. The exception is the pandemic period. The relationship between trade dynamics and the G7 group changed after COVID-19.

2. Was the effect caused by energy prices?

Electricity prices in the UK are now among the highest in industrialized countries. To test this hypothesis, the growth of electricity prices is compared with the decline in goods exports.

Sweden showed the largest growth in electricity prices in recent years. The rise in UK prices corresponds to the general dynamics of most developed economies. At the same time, the decline in UK goods exports was stronger than in most other countries. Consequently, energy prices do not explain the entire decline.

3. Was the decline caused by a general European trend?

To test this, the competitiveness of UK economic sectors is compared with similar sectors in other countries. Sectors where competitiveness is growing are located above zero. Sectors where it is declining are located below zero.

Germany, France, and the US show growth in competitiveness in a number of sectors. In the UK, there are more negative indicators than positive ones. Among the sectors with declining competitiveness are:

  • optical equipment;
  • oil and gas extraction;
  • footwear production.

The greatest concern is caused by the dynamics in strategic industrial policy sectors, such as semiconductors and advanced chemicals. Exports of these goods from European countries are growing. Exports of such goods from the UK are declining.

Trade with the EU

Britain's share of EU imports fell sharply at the end of the transition period, when the new rules came into effect. The decline continued after that.

Imports from the EU into Britain remained stable throughout the period. Britain kept its openness to trade with Europe. The EU did not show the same openness. Questions of aligning trade conditions were to be discussed at the upcoming summit.

Migration

Net migration from the EU to the UK fell to negative values after the end of the transition period. Net migration from non-EU countries rose sharply. This growth has no precedent in the history of the UK.

During and after the pandemic, the dynamics were unstable. However, the sharp change in migration policy coincided with new rules introduced after Brexit. Migration policy became one of the key outcomes of leaving the EU.

Revision of Productivity Estimates

The UK government has recently published new data suggesting that the previously published estimate of labour productivity may have been understated. According to the new estimate, the United Kingdom ranks higher in international comparisons. Official statistics do not yet reflect this revision. If the revision is confirmed, some analyses of the impact of Brexit will need to be revised.

Scale of the Effect in the Context of the Economy

The main contributors to UK economic growth over the past two years are services: finance, professional services, and retail trade. The share of manufacturing is small.

The Bank of England estimates that about one fifth of economic growth over the past couple of years is attributable to sectors linked to artificial intelligence. Some analysts believe this share is even larger.

For comparison, the best-case scenario of the agreement under discussion at the summit is estimated to add about 0.4 percentage points to GDP. This effect is small compared with other factors of economic growth.

Economists assess this result in different ways. Some believe it justifies the effort. Others point out that strong growth in the artificial intelligence sector is partly explained by more liberal regulation in the UK.

Conclusions

The data confirm the impact of Brexit on trade in goods, competitiveness in high-tech sectors, and migration. The magnitude of the overall effect remains a subject of debate. Estimates range from 4% to 7% of GDP. The forecasts made in 2016, which predicted a sharp downturn, have not been borne out. The question of how large the effect is and how significant the measures discussed at the summit will be remains open.

The "Project Fear" Forecasts and Reality

The Treasury's predictions of catastrophe after Brexit did not come true: GDP grew, unemployment fell, house prices rose, and the pound fell only 10% instead of the forecast 12–15%.

  • The Treasury forecast a 3.6% GDP decline under a mild shock and about 5–6% under a severe one
  • In fact, GDP grew in the two years after the referendum
  • Unemployment was projected to rise by 1.6–2.4%, but in reality it fell
  • House prices were projected to fall by 10–18%, but in reality they rose by about 7%
  • The pound was projected to fall by 12–15%, but in fact it fell by 10%

Damage Estimates and the "Synthetic Control" Method

Estimates of Brexit's impact on the economy vary widely: NBER gives about 7%, OBR about 4%. The estimates rely on the "synthetic control" method, which compares the UK with a group of similar countries.

  • Oxford Economics, Open Europe and Economists for Brexit forecast economic growth, while most economists expected a decline
  • A study by the National Bureau of Economic Research (USA) estimates the effect at roughly 7%
  • The OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) estimates the effect at around 4%, averaging other people's forecasts
  • The "synthetic control" method compares UK growth and investment with a group of countries that were similar to Great Britain before 2016
  • After 2016 the trajectories diverge; the gap is the estimate of the cost of Brexit

The Outlier Problem: USA and the G7

Excluding the USA from the comparison changes the result: the United Kingdom sits in the middle of the G7 group, and US growth distorts the picture. Without the USA the gap is smaller, but the UK's position is still higher than expected.

  • In terms of GDP per capita, the United Kingdom is roughly in the middle of the G7
  • The United Kingdom is ahead of France and Italy
  • The USA, with unusually high growth, is the outlier in the G7 group
  • Without the USA, the gap with the synthetic twin shrinks but remains positive

Factors: Trade, Energy, Europe

Three questions: was this really Brexit, what role do energy prices play, and how does the UK look relative to Europe. The data shows the impact of Brexit on goods trade and high-tech industries.

  • The United Kingdom has traditionally been strong in services exports, and since 2005 has been almost in first place
  • In goods exports, the UK's ranking has steadily declined; China is at the top
  • After the referendum, the growth of UK goods exports became one of the lowest in the G7
  • The UK's share of EU imports fell sharply at the end of the transition period and continued to decline
  • Imports from the EU to the UK remained stable, while the EU restricted imports from the UK
  • UK electricity prices rose, but the fall in goods exports is greater than energy can explain; the largest energy price increase was in Sweden
  • In terms of sector competitiveness, the UK lost ground in most industries; exports of important sectors (semiconductors, advanced chemicals) to the EU are growing, while those from the UK are falling

Migration after Brexit

Migration changed sharply after the end of the transition period: net migration from the EU fell below zero, migration from non-EU countries rose sharply, and then began to decline.

  • New migration rules came into force after the end of the transition period
  • Net migration from the EU fell below zero
  • Net migration from non-EU countries grew unprecedentedly
  • Migration is now falling sharply, but the pandemic is distorting the data

Data Revision and Outlook

New government productivity data may revise estimates of Brexit's impact. The actual effect on the economy scale is noticeable but small compared with the growth of the AI sector.

  • The government recently published new productivity data, which may be revised in an optimistic direction
  • Estimates of Brexit's impact may need to be revised
  • According to the Bank of England, about a fifth of economic growth over the past couple of years is linked to the AI sector
  • A potential agreement at the summit could add about 0.4 percentage points of GDP, which is small compared with other sectors
  • The UK's growth in AI is linked, according to some economists, to more liberal regulation