~4m14:35Richard Johns talks about Langara's Cancellation
Nov 16, 2026
Read: ~4m · You save: 11 min
Richard Johns talks about Langara's Cancellation
Retired philosophy professor Richard Johns says Langara College cancelled his critical thinking talk on residential schools, breaching its free speech policy. Hear his
Overview
Richard Johns, a retired philosophy professor from Langara College, says the college cancelled his planned talk on critical thinking and Indian residential schools. The talk was scheduled for November 24, 2025, as part of the college's Philosophers Jam series. Johns retired in September 2025.
Background to the Talk
Johns had given talks on current issues using critical thinking before. He had long considered addressing residential schools but said he was nervous about doing so while employed at the college, given the subject's sensitivity and the risk of being "canceled." After retiring, he discussed the topic with the Philosophy Jam coordinator. Johns said he expressed reservations about possible cancellation, but the coordinator said the talk should proceed. The coordinator argued that the philosophy department is expected to examine controversial issues, such as abortion and euthanasia, and that the subject was legitimate.
Johns researched the topic, submitted an abstract, and the event was advertised and a room was booked.
Changes to the Event
About one week before the scheduled date, the college provost began sending emails about the event. Johns said that someone alerted the provost to the talk. Initially, the provost proposed broadening and diversifying the voices at the event. Graham Joseph of Indigenous Engagement would give comments after Johns's talk and before audience questions. Johns agreed and said he viewed the arrangement as a way to start debate and present more than one perspective.
Joseph then said he was not prepared to speak within one week and requested more time. A postponement was proposed. Johns said the discussion showed that the change was not a postponement but a replacement of the Philosophy Jam with a different event.
Johns and the event organizer said they were willing to participate in the college's future event but intended to hold their own event unless it was cancelled. The exchange continued, and the Langara Faculty Association (LFA) became involved. Johns said the parties consulted lawyers. The college ultimately stated that the event could not proceed. The college continued to use the term "postponement" and never used the word "cancelled." The college cancelled the room booking and the catering.
Johns said the event was held off campus, at an Indian restaurant.
Replacement Meeting
A meeting about the replacement event was scheduled shortly after the talk date. Johns said that around the same time, a notice moved the meeting, and the meeting was then cancelled. The college said it would reschedule, but the meeting never took place. Johns said his emails to the provost asking about the meeting went unanswered.
The Philosophers Jam Series
Johns described the Philosophers Jam as community outreach. The series is advertised across Vancouver to attract attendees and raise the college's profile. Each session includes a presentation of 30 to 60 minutes, followed by about one hour of audience discussion. The series is modeled on the SFU Philosophers Café and focuses on sensitive, contentious topics and views. Its byline is "provocateurs wanted."
Decision-Making
Johns said an individual who attended the talk told him that a senior administrator above the provost made the final decision. Johns said he did not know whether he should share this information because it was unverified and that the source's account was speculative.
Freedom of Expression Policy
Johns said Langara has a freedom of expression policy. Under the policy, individuals or groups in the college community, including professors, may ask the administration to review a planned talk. A free speech committee reviews such requests. Cancellation requires one of four criteria, which are strict. Johns said none applied to his talk, such as illegality or harassment. He said the cancellation therefore violated the college's own policy. He described the college's use of the word "postponement" as verbal sleight of hand.
Johns said he was unaware of the policy at the time and would have filed a formal complaint had he known.
Union Involvement
Two union representatives appeared in the email chains. Johns said he did not know the union's position, as he had never asked. He said the union strongly supported Natalie Knight, whose free speech was upheld, although she resigned after reinstatement. Johns said he did not fully support Knight's views but backed her reinstatement. The Greater Vancouver LFA also supported her.
Johns said he did not follow the Knight case closely. He understood that complaints of antisemitism from Jewish students led to a suspension, that she later acted in a way that may have breached conditions placed on her, and that she was eventually reinstated before resigning.
Johns said Knight's speech lacked academic qualities, including footnotes, arguments, and appeals to evidence. He described it as a diatribe against Israel that celebrated its destruction. He said he believes his own case for academic freedom is stronger than hers.
Content of the Talk
The talk was structured around five statements made by Murray Sinclair at the UN before the start of the TRC hearings. Johns fact-checked each statement. He rated some as mostly or partially true, and he judged most as seriously flawed or completely false. He based his analysis on primary documents, historical records, and academic sources.
The talk concluded with a review of the Kamloops case. Johns relied mainly on Francis's paper "Billy Remembers" and other sources. He agreed with its conclusion that evidence for bodies at the site is very thin and that substantial evidence exists against the claim.
The talk was not recorded because of audiovisual problems. Johns's slides are available on his website.
Planned Follow-Up
The interviewer proposed a Zoom event in which Johns would present his slides. The interviewer stated that the group planned to visit Langara College to test the cancellation and to conduct a discussion using Street Epistemology. The interviewer expected that Langara would be calmer than other institutions, such as UBC and Brock University, but that the outcome was uncertain.
Planning the Talk
Johns was nervous about the topic while employed, but after retiring in September 2025 he proposed the talk; the coordinator approved it.
- Johns retired in September 2025 and had previously given critical thinking talks on current issues.
- He wanted to address critical thinking regarding Indian residential schools but feared cancellation while employed.
- After retiring, he spoke with the Philosophy Jam coordinator, who said it should be fine.
- The talk was advertised, a room was booked, and an abstract was published.
Administrative Response and Cancellation
About a week before the event, the provost emailed, proposing an Indigenous Engagement response by Graham Joseph; this evolved into a replacement of the event.
- Roughly one week before the date, emails from the provost began; someone in the department reportedly alerted the provost.
- Initially the provost proposed broadening voices with comments from Indigenous Engagement's Graham Joseph before audience questions.
- Joseph reportedly was not prepared to speak within one week, and a postponement was suggested.
- Johns viewed the arrangement as a cancellation and replacement rather than a postponement.
- The college cancelled the room booking and catering, and said the event could not go ahead; the LFA and lawyers were consulted.
- The talk was held off campus at an Indian restaurant.
The Replacement Meeting and the Philosophy Jam
The replacement meeting was postponed, then never happened; Johns was not answered by the provost.
- A meeting about the replacement event was scheduled after the talk date but was moved and then cancelled.
- Johns emailed the provost for a new date and received no reply.
- The Philosophy Jam is community outreach open to the public, advertised around the city, with 30 to 60 minute presentations followed by about an hour of discussion.
- The series is modeled on the SFU Philosophers Cafe; its byline is 'provocateurs wanted'.
Freedom of Expression Policy
Johns argues the cancellation violated Langara's freedom of expression policy, which has four stringent criteria for cancelling talks; the decision was reportedly made above the provost.
- Langara's policy allows members to request review of talks; a free speech committee reviews them against four stringent criteria.
- None of the criteria, such as illegality or harassment, applied to Johns's talk.
- Johns believes the college knew it breached its policy and used 'postponed' as verbal sleight of hand.
- Johns heard, unconfirmed, that a figure above the provost made the final decision.
Union Role and the Natalie Knight Case
Union representatives were copied on emails, but Johns never asked them their position; the union supported Natalie Knight, whose free speech was upheld before she resigned.
- Two union representatives were included in the email chains without visible objections.
- Johns was not aware of the union's position and never asked them.
- The union and the LFA supported Natalie Knight, whose free speech was eventually upheld.
- Knight was reportedly suspended after antisemitism complaints, later reinstated, and then resigned.
- Johns argues Knight's speech lacked academic qualities and so had a weaker freedom of expression claim than his own.
The Talk's Content
Johns's talk critiques five statements by Murray Sinclair at the UN before the TRC hearings, and he analyzes the Kamloops burial claims, finding thin evidence for bodies.
- The talk fact-checked five statements by Murray Sinclair made at the UN before the TRC hearings; most were seriously flawed or false.
- He relied on primary and historical documents and academic sources.
- For the Kamloops case he drew mainly on Francis's paper 'Billy Remembers' and concluded evidence for bodies is very thin, with substantial evidence against.
- The talk was not recorded due to AV problems; slides are on his website and a Zoom presentation was suggested.
Planned Street Epistemology at Langara
The interviewer plans to take the discussion to Langara with street epistemology maps and expects a calmer reception than at UBC or other schools.
- The interviewer plans street epistemology at Langara College, referencing the November 24, 2025 talk.
- Johns expects a calmer reception at Langara than at UBC, which he described as difficult, and at other institutions.
- The interviewer compares the situation to Brock University and OISE, and believes Langara will allow the exercise.