~11m12:19
апвоут

Психотерапевты, чем отличается психика парней и девушек?

Jul 31, 2025

Read: ~11m · You save: 1 min

Psychotherapists on the Differences in the Psyche of Men and Women

Psychotherapists share how gender shapes emotions, anger, openness, and self-esteem, and why many differences trace back to upbringing and culture.

Severe Mental Disorders

One psychotherapist worked with people suffering from psychoses and schizophrenia. In his observations, men more often had delusional ideas of a religious nature: "I am God" or "God is speaking to me." Women more often had erotomanic delusions. One patient claimed that Michael Jackson was speaking to him, and called himself the Virgin Mary, who had miraculously become pregnant.

Disorders associated with dissociation occurred with approximately equal frequency. The typical content of such delusional ideas: "This world is not real," "People have been replaced by zombies," "You are not my mother."

Intimacy Issues in Therapy

A psychotherapist who specializes in intimacy issues notes differences in the requests of couples and single patients. When a couple comes in, the woman usually wants her partner to read her mind. The man, as a rule, wants to receive a complete instruction manual.

Single men aged 40–50 often want to restore their sexual function to the way it was when they were 17.

Gender Differences in Adolescents

One psychotherapist works with foster children aged 2 to 18. He provides them with therapeutic support and helps ensure stability in their living arrangements.

In his observations, gender differences are almost imperceptible until the age of 9–11. In adolescence, they become obvious.

Adolescent girls:

  • more often try to control the situation: they refuse meetings or ignore communication;
  • in most cases, they are open and glad of the opportunity to finally be heard.

Adolescent boys:

  • are usually glad of the chance to get out of the house, since this seems interesting to them;
  • more often try to take control of the situation: they throw the therapist off balance, flirt awkwardly, make inappropriate jokes, or are rude.

Patient Disclosure Speed

In the author's experience, men open up faster. During the first one or two visits they are very reserved, and then suddenly they tell everything.

Women, on the other hand, are open from the very start. However, they reveal important details slowly.

Pain, Depression, and Alexithymia

Many older men who complain of physical pain actually have depression. This is often linked to alexithymia, a condition in which a person cannot recognize, express, or feel their own emotions. It is often caused by suppressing emotions or by never having developed this skill.

In such people, most often men, psychological problems frequently appear as physical symptoms.

It is commonly believed that doctors constantly tell women their pain is "all in their head," while men's pain is taken seriously as real. The author argues that the reality is actually the opposite.

Initiative in Seeking Help

Men often book their first appointment with a psychotherapist because their wife or girlfriend pushed them to. Much less often do they seek help on their own initiative.

Needs of Men and Women in Relationships

The author concluded that men need support and approval in order to feel well. Constant criticism undermines their self-confidence. In such a state, it is difficult for them to build a relationship with a partner.

Women above all need attention. It is important for them to feel that they are noticed and heard. Complete understanding matters less to them than the sense that they are being listened to. Explanations and justifications usually do not satisfy them. They need their feelings to be acknowledged.

If a woman does not feel that she is noticed and heard, she does not feel loved. This makes it harder for her to connect with her partner.

Communication in a Couple

The author is not a psychotherapist, but she takes part in communities devoted to relationship therapy. She notes a pattern: men often perceive their partner's words as criticism. The reason is that they feel personally responsible for the family's success and see their partner as a member of the team.

An example from the author's observations:

  • The woman says: "Let's figure this out together."
  • The man hears: "Sort it out yourself, or you're a failure."

As a result, the man starts defending himself every time his partner raises the subject. She feels that she is not being heard, because he immediately withdraws. The tension destroys the relationship, and the man becomes increasingly convinced of his own inadequacy.

Emotional Differences

According to the author, the differences between men and women are smaller than they might seem.

Men do tend to express emotions through anger. They usually have fewer supportive relationships, and they are less likely to open up to loved ones about their psychoemotional state. According to the author, these traits are more a consequence of social upbringing than innate qualities.

Paradoxically, the author observes that men are even more inclined than women to idealize love and romantic relationships.

Men, as a rule, first feel sadness, disappointment, or vulnerability, and then almost instantly begin to get angry at the very fact of having these feelings. Women, as a rule, accept sadness more easily. However, later they may feel sorrow or guilt for having gotten angry or lashed out.

The author says these observations are based on Western experience. In her view, the main cause of the differences is culture. Attitudes such as "a sad guy is a wimp" and "an angry woman" remain very persistent.

Working with Male and Female Clients

A psychotherapist who works with both men and women describes the differences in what they bring to therapy.

Men come to therapy expecting concrete solutions and structure. They want the therapist, as a woman, to speak directly. Over time, however, almost always a deep psychodynamic process begins. It includes:

  • a lot of conversation and open, guiding questions;
  • awareness of childhood relational themes and behavioral patterns;
  • working through deeper topics that clients previously considered unimportant or did not feel able to talk about.

Women are usually very successful, in control of their situations, and often perfectionists. They are burned out and tend to approach therapy and self-healing in an idealized way, as a project. Over time, the following themes emerge in the work:

  • self-acceptance;
  • working through anger;
  • personal boundaries;
  • values-based action;
  • self-image;
  • awareness of gender roles and capitalism.

The work involves not only analyzing emotions but also fully experiencing them.

According to the therapist's observations, clients often already have a high level of self-reflection. They know what they feel, are able to describe it, and understand their situation. What they need is a safe and reliable connection with a therapist who gently challenges them to be truly honest with themselves. Growth is impossible without a certain amount of discomfort, so the ability to look inward and recognize the obstacles on the path to change gradually develops.

Findings of a Study on Gender Differences in Therapy

About 20 years ago, one of the authors conducted a study on gender differences in therapy. He identified two general tendencies:

  1. Men tend to downplay the severity of their condition. They would say they felt better than they actually did, or that they were satisfied with the therapist, when in fact they were only moderately satisfied.
  2. Men generally express themselves less verbally than women. Alexithymia was also much more common among them. The inability to recognize their feelings and explore them without professional help had a truly devastating effect on many men.

The author clarified that these were observations made during therapy sessions, not the results of a formalized study.

Breakups

One psychotherapist works with many college students. According to him, young men take breakups much harder. They are more likely to cry over a breakup.

He also quoted a line he heard from a comedian, which struck him as logical: "Women handle breakups so easily because they break up with you a month before they tell you. That's why they want to stay friends afterward. You were the guy who helped her get over the breakup. Only with you."

Gender Issues in Client Requests

Gender issues are common among clients or, at the very least, significantly shape their requests for therapy.

Women:

  • Some difficulties are rooted in attitudes, events, and relationship patterns imposed by patriarchal culture.
  • Some find it hard to build friendships, especially in groups where social aggression between women is common. Women with autism experience this particularly acutely.
  • Some have a well-founded fear of possible violence from men and avoid any contact with them, even when they want to build relationships.
  • Others suffer from the pressure of standards of female appearance. This shows up as low self-esteem and a distorted perception of their own body if they do not meet these standards. If they do meet them, they experience confusion and discomfort from constant objectification. Objectification can come from both men and women.

Men:

  • loneliness and the absence of close friendships;
  • difficulty expressing emotions or a complete lack of interest in emotional openness, including with a partner;
  • emotional detachment in romantic relationships;
  • negative attitudes toward women, which are often fueled by masculinist internet content;
  • guilt over supposedly being a burden to their family or society, especially when they feel pressure from a wife or girlfriend;
  • overgeneralized and hostile views of women, for example, the belief that all women are stupid, selfish, and superficial. Such views interfere with building healthy relationships both as a couple and in other areas of life.

The author notes that such views are regularly encountered online as well. Gender conflicts also manifest in therapeutic practice.

The author considers this sad. The system deeply embeds and sustains these problems, and therapists cannot work directly with their source. The therapist's task is to help each person develop the skills and views that will protect them from the most destructive manifestations of this system.

Expressions of Anger

A trainee psychotherapist notes that one of the most noticeable differences is how anger is expressed.

Women:

  • often experience suppressed anger, which they deny until it erupts;
  • sometimes fail to realize that they have a problem with anger;
  • suppress the expression of anger out of fear of being called overly sensitive or hysterical.

Men learn from childhood that anger is the only acceptable emotion. As a result, they often deny depression, anxiety, and other negative feelings that underlie anger. Other men are so afraid of becoming like the angry men around them that they completely forbid themselves from expressing anger.

Clinical Practice and Emotional Openness

A clinical psychologist who works with adults and older adolescents, specializing in trauma, anxiety and depressive disorders, and eating and sleep disorders, believes that gender differences in psychotherapy are persistent and largely reflect social attitudes.

Men struggle to allow themselves emotional openness within a session. They prefer rational analysis, reflection, and problem-solving. When faced with a strong feeling, they often freeze. Behind this almost always lies a core belief: "I don't want to feel this." The main focus of the work should be not so much on the emotions themselves as on the attitude toward them.

Women also show emotional guardedness, but it is usually rooted in traumatic experience. For example, if a father beat a child every time the child showed feelings, it is unsurprising that the child learned to be completely unfeeling. In men, this detachment is often present from the start, even without an explicit traumatic history. This says a great deal about how boys are taught to handle emotions from childhood.

The psychologist quotes bell hooks, paraphrased: "The first violence that a boy experiences in patriarchy is the violence done to his own capacity for feeling."

Self-Esteem and Inner Confidence

Women more often come to therapy with anxiety, self-doubt, and concern about their appearance and how others perceive them. They tend to evaluate even their own thoughts through the lens of other people's opinions. Men experience this too, but it is usually linked to traumatic experience, most often with a male figure, such as a father.

In general, men have more inner confidence by default. Most women whom the psychologist works with hold a deeply rooted belief: "Something is wrong with me, I am not good enough."

According to the psychologist, this is to be expected. In patriarchal culture, women for centuries did not have equal rights. They were not allowed to manage money or take part in decision-making. Survival depended directly on how much they pleased men and were accepted by society. They had to find a husband, bear a child, and be accepted into the community.

Therefore, the desire to be attractive, especially in the eyes of men, is neither a whim nor superficiality. It is the legacy of millennia, including cultural and possibly epigenetic inheritance.

Even women with progressive views, who are able to build independent lives, often continue internally to struggle with the feeling that they are not good enough. This struggle can undermine even intelligent, kind, and strong women. Such women would like to direct their energy toward important matters, but again and again they find themselves under the power of insecurity, fear, and anxiety.

Reaction to Conflict

In conflict situations, women more often blame themselves. Shame, fear, and guilt come to the forefront. Men primarily experience anger.

According to the psychologist, this is not only because boys are forbidden from being vulnerable from childhood. One of his clients was shamed as a child for any display of weakness. Another reason is that men more often feel entitled to express their opinions. Society recognizes them as full-fledged people whose feelings and thoughts matter.

For girls, this right is often taken away from an early age. They are taught to doubt themselves, to adapt, and to be accommodating. They are less often allowed to express anger. If a woman is not sure that her feelings matter, she is unlikely to allow herself to be angry.

Psychoses and Schizophrenia: Delusional Ideas

A psychotherapist who worked with psychoses and schizophrenia describes gender differences in the content of delusional ideas.

  • Men more often had delusional ideas about God ("I am God", "God is with me").
  • Women more often had erotomanic delusions (love delusions).
  • Dissociation-related disorders occurred at roughly the same frequency in both sexes.
  • Examples of delusional ideas: "This world is not real", "People have been replaced by zombies", "You are not my mother".

Teenagers and Foster Children

A psychotherapist working with foster children aged 2 to 18 describes behavioral differences between adolescents by gender.

  • Until roughly ages 9–11 there are almost no gender differences; they become noticeable in adolescence.
  • Teenage girls are more likely to take control of the situation, refusing meetings or ignoring communication.
  • Teenage boys usually are glad of the chance to get out of the house.
  • Teenage girls are more often open and are glad to be listened to.
  • Teenage boys are more likely to try to seize control, throw the therapist off balance, flirt awkwardly, make inappropriate jokes, or be rude.

Openness in Therapy, Depression, and Alexithymia

In the narrator's experience, men open up later in therapy but more sharply, while women start out candid, yet reveal important details slowly.

  • Men are very reserved during the first one or two visits, then suddenly reveal everything.
  • Women are more open from the start, but they disclose important details slowly.
  • Many older men who complain of physical pain are actually suffering from depression.
  • This is often linked to alexithymia: a person cannot recognize, express, or feel their emotions, often due to suppression or lack of such a skill.
  • In people with alexithymia, who are more often men, psychological problems frequently appear as physical symptoms.
  • Doctors often tell women that their pain is "in their head," and treat men's pain as real, although, according to the narrator, it is actually the other way around.
  • Men more often come to a psychotherapist at the urging of a wife or girlfriend, and much less often on their own initiative.

Relationship Needs and the Perception of Criticism

The narrator describes the different needs of men and women in relationships and the causes of conflicts linked to how criticism is perceived.

  • For their well-being, men need support and approval; constant criticism undermines their self-confidence.
  • Women above all need attention: it is important to feel that they are noticed and heard.
  • It is not as important for women to be fully understood; what matters more is the feeling that they are being listened to.
  • Women usually do not benefit from explanations or justifications; they need their feelings to be acknowledged.
  • If a woman does not feel noticed and heard, she does not feel loved, which makes contact with her partner difficult.
  • Men often perceive a partner's words as criticism because they feel personal responsibility for the family's success.
  • A woman's phrase "Let's figure it out together" is often heard by a man as "Figure it out yourself, or you're a failure."
  • The man becomes defensive and withdraws, and the conflict in the relationship escalates.

Anger, Culture, and Differences Between the Sexes

Differences between the sexes are largely linked to social upbringing rather than innate traits; men more often express emotions through anger.

  • Men more often express emotions through anger, and less often have supportive connections or open up to those close to them.
  • According to the narrator, these are more likely consequences of social upbringing than innate characteristics.
  • Men, even more than women, tend to idealize love and romantic relationships.
  • Men often first feel sadness, disappointment, or vulnerability, and then almost instantly get angry at the very fact of having these feelings.
  • Women more readily accept sadness, but may later feel sorrow or guilt for having gotten angry or lashed out.
  • The narrator says these observations are based on his Western experience.
  • According to the narrator, the main cause of the differences is cultural. Attitudes like "a sad guy is a weakling" and "an angry woman" remain very persistent.

Working with Male and Female Clients

The narrator describes how male and female clients come to therapy and how the work with them develops.

  • Male clients expect concrete solutions, structure, and for the female therapist to speak directly.
  • Over time, work with men almost always moves toward deep psychodynamic work.
  • Such work involves a lot of conversation, open guiding questions, and awareness of childhood relational themes and behavioral patterns.
  • Men begin to voice deeper things that they previously considered unimportant or were not allowed to talk about.
  • Female clients are usually successful, controlling, perfectionistic, and burned out.
  • Women try to carry out therapy and self-healing in a perfect way, as a project.
  • Over time, work with women covers self-acceptance, working through anger, personal boundaries, value-based actions, and self-image.
  • Gender roles and capitalism are also addressed, and emotions are not only analyzed but also fully experienced.

Self-Reflection of Female Clients and a 20-Year-Old Study

Female clients often have high self-reflection, so they need not just help understanding themselves, but a safe connection with an honest therapist. The narrator also shares results of his research from twenty years ago.

  • Female clients often already know what they feel, can describe it, and understand their situation.
  • They need a safe and reliable connection with a psychotherapist who will gently challenge them to be truly honest with themselves.
  • Growth is impossible without a certain amount of discomfort.
  • Twenty years ago, the narrator studied gender differences in therapy.
  • One finding: men tend to understate the severity of their condition and say they feel better or are satisfied with the therapist, although they were only moderately satisfied.
  • Second tendency: men generally express themselves less verbally than women.
  • Alexithymia was much more common among men, and the inability to recognize feelings without professional help had a devastating effect.
  • The observation was made within therapy sessions, not in a formalized study.

Breakups

The narrator talks about the different ways people experience breakups and how men and women perceive the end of relationships differently.

  • The narrator works with many college students and believes that guys take breakups harder.
  • Guys cry more often over breakups.
  • According to a comedian's joke, women handle breakups easily because they end things a month before they tell the other person.
  • That is why, after a breakup, women often want to stay friends, since their former partner helped them get through the breakup.

Clients' Gender Issues and the Influence of Culture

Gender-related problems of clients are often linked to patriarchal culture, fear of violence, pressure of appearance standards, and difficulties with friendship and loneliness.

  • Women's difficulties often stem from attitudes, events, and relationships imposed by patriarchal culture.
  • Some women find it hard to build friendships because of social aggression between women, and women with autism feel this especially acutely.
  • Some women avoid contact with men out of a well-founded fear of violence, even when they want relationships.
  • Others suffer from the pressure of appearance standards: low self-esteem, distorted perception of their body, or discomfort from constant objectification.
  • Objectification can come from both men and women.
  • Men experience loneliness, lack of close friendships, difficulty expressing emotions, and emotional detachment in relationships.
  • Men's negative attitudes toward women are often fueled by misogynistic internet content (in the text: "masculinist internet content").
  • Some men feel guilty, believing they are a burden to their family or society, especially under pressure from a wife or girlfriend.
  • Some men hold overly generalized and hostile views of women, considering them all stupid, mercenary, and superficial, which prevents them from building healthy relationships.

Systemic Problems and the Role of the Therapist

Gender wars also show up in therapy, and therapists can only help people develop skills that protect them from the destructive influence of the system.

  • Gender conflicts that occur online also manifest in therapeutic practice.
  • The system deeply embeds and sustains these problems, and therapists cannot directly work with their source.
  • The therapist's task is to help each person develop skills and perspectives that will protect them from the most destructive manifestations of this system.

Anger and Suppression of Emotions

Anger shows up differently: women often suppress it, while men deny other feelings, including depression and anxiety.

  • The narrator is an intern in psychotherapy and notes that one of the most striking differences is how anger is expressed.
  • Women often feel suppressed anger, which they deny until it erupts, or they fail to recognize their problem with anger.
  • Women may suppress anger out of fear of being called overly sensitive or hysterical.
  • From childhood, men are taught that anger is the only emotion that is acceptable.
  • As a result, men often deny depression, anxiety, and other feelings that underlie anger.
  • Some men are so afraid of becoming like the angry men around them that they forbid others from expressing anger.

Clinical Practice: Emotional Openness and Trauma

A clinical psychologist describes the persistence of gender differences in therapy, men's reluctance to be emotionally open, and the specifics of working with women who often have traumatic experiences and low self-esteem.

  • The clinical psychologist works with adults and older adolescents and specializes in trauma, anxiety and depressive disorders, eating disorders, and sleep disorders.
  • Gender differences in psychotherapy are persistent and largely reflect social attitudes.
  • Men find it harder to allow themselves emotional openness in a session; they prefer rational analysis, reflection, and searching for solutions.
  • When faced with a strong feeling, men often freeze, and behind this there is almost always the belief: "I don't want to feel this."
  • The main focus of the work should be placed not so much on the emotions themselves as on the attitude toward them.
  • Emotional withdrawal in women is usually rooted in traumatic experience, for example in violence from a father.
  • In men, detachment is often present from the very beginning, even without an explicit traumatic history.
  • A paraphrased quote from bell hooks: "The first violence a boy commits under patriarchy is violence against his own sensitivity."

Self-Esteem and the Legacy of Patriarchy

Women more often come in with anxiety and self-doubt, while men usually have greater inner confidence. This is considered to be rooted in women's historical lack of rights.

  • Women more often come in with anxiety, self-doubt, concern about their appearance, and how others perceive them.
  • Women evaluate even their own thoughts through the lens of others' opinions.
  • Men experience this too, but it is usually linked to traumatic experiences, most often with their father or another male figure.
  • Most of the women the narrator works with have a deeply rooted feeling: "Something is wrong with me, I am not good enough."
  • In patriarchal culture, women for centuries were not given equal rights, were not allowed to manage money or take part in decision-making.
  • Women's survival depended on how much they pleased men or were accepted by society: finding a husband, bearing children, being accepted into the community.
  • The drive to be attractive is a legacy of millennia, both cultural and possibly epigenetic.
  • Even progressive and independent women often struggle internally with the sense that they are not good enough.

Guilt, Anger, and the Right to Express Feelings

Women in conflict more often blame themselves, while men experience anger. The difference is linked to the right to express opinions that each gender's society grants them.

  • In conflict situations, women more often blame themselves; their primary feelings are shame, fear, and guilt.
  • Men primarily feel anger.
  • Boys are forbidden from being vulnerable from childhood; the narrator recalls a client who was shamed as a child for any display of weakness.
  • Men more often feel entitled to express their opinions; society recognizes them as full people whose feelings and thoughts matter.
  • Girls are often deprived of this right from an early age: they are taught to doubt themselves, adapt, and be accommodating.
  • Girls are less often allowed to show anger, because if a woman is not sure her feelings matter, she cannot allow herself to be angry.