~3m6:21
Liym Ete

🎯 Good Strategy Bad Strategy: Analysis and Principles

Feb 2, 2026

Read: ~3m · You save: 3 min

Good Strategy Bad Strategy: Analysis and Principles

Why are most 'strategies' just pretty wishes? We break down Rumelt's book, the core of good strategy, and Apple's revival in 1997.

The word "strategy" is among the most frequently used and, probably, the most misused terms in business. People speak of strategic plans, strategic initiatives, and strategic thinking. However, most of what is called strategy is not strategy at all.

The key question is this: does a strategy represent a concrete plan for overcoming a problem, or is it more of a hope, a dream, and a list of desired outcomes? In Good Strategy/Bad Strategy, Richard Rumelt points out that strategy is not defined only by what you want. It is defined by how you will achieve it, by overcoming the obstacles along the way.

The Strategic Illusion

Rumelt calls the common confusion between real strategy and what merely masquerades as strategy the strategic illusion. The illusion arises when a vague vision or ambitious goals are mistaken for a coherent plan.

Real strategy requires difficult choices. It entails giving up many good ideas in favor of a few of the best. Bad strategy tries to please everyone and, as a result, achieves nothing.

Four Signs of a Bad Strategy

  1. Empty words. Pseudo-scientific jargon and buzzwords sound impressive but mean nothing.
  2. Avoiding the problem. If you cannot clearly name the problem the strategy is meant to solve, there is no strategy.
  3. Replacing strategy with goals. The statement "our goal is to be first" describes an objective but not a plan for achieving it.
  4. Weak strategic actions. A list of tasks unrelated to the main challenge is not a strategy.

The Core of a Good Strategy

Rumelt proposes a simple framework, which he calls the kernel of a good strategy. A good strategy is a set of coordinated actions supported by clear logic. The framework is understandable to any employee in the organization. A strategy does not have to be a multi-page document that nobody reads.

The kernel includes three elements:

  • Diagnosis. Separating the essential from the complexity and noise and understanding what is actually happening. Rumelt compares this stage to the work of a doctor who makes a diagnosis.
  • Guiding policy. The overall approach to addressing the identified problem.
  • Coherent actions. Specific, coordinated steps that turn the policy into reality.

The formula is simple: diagnosis, policy, action.

Example: Apple in 1997

In 1997, Apple was a few weeks away from bankruptcy. The company was producing dozens of different products, supporting several operating systems, and its resources were scattered throughout the organization.

Steve Jobs, who had returned to the company, did not consider poor sales or low profits to be the cause of the crisis. He viewed them as symptoms. The diagnosis was different: a paralyzing lack of focus. Leadership policy followed from the diagnosis. Apple had to direct all of its energy and all of its talent toward creating a small number of products and making them exceptional.

Coordinated actions were subordinated to this policy:

  • the product line was cut down to nearly four items;
  • the company abandoned printers and other peripheral devices.

Each action served the goal of radical simplification and directly addressed the identified problem.

The result was not only that the company was saved from bankruptcy. The focused strategy became the foundation for the iPod and iPhone and allowed Apple to become the most valuable company in the world. A good strategy creates power through the concentration of energy.

Comparing Approaches

Bad StrategyGood Strategy
Avoids difficult choicesMakes hard decisions
Is a wish listIs a coherent plan for overcoming obstacles
Relies on pseudo-scientific jargonProvides a clear focus
Copies competitors' actionsOffers a unique solution to a unique challenge

Conclusions

Strategy means making choices. It requires clarity and a willingness to focus limited time, money, and energy on what matters most, consciously letting go of everything else.

A practical question to test this: what would happen if, instead of listing goals and aspirations, you began with an honest diagnosis of the real situation? That shift could be the beginning of a truly strong strategy.

Introduction: What Is Strategy

Strategy is often replaced by a list of wishes and attractive phrases. A real strategy is a concrete plan for overcoming obstacles.

  • The term "strategy" is overused in business, including "strategic plans," "strategic initiatives," and "strategic thinking"
  • A strategy must be a concrete plan for overcoming a challenge, not a hope or a list of desires
  • A quote from Richard Rumelt's "Good Strategy, Bad Strategy": strategy is not simply what you want, but how you will achieve the goal by overcoming obstacles

Strategic Illusion and Four Signs of Bad Strategy

Strategic illusion is the confusion between real strategy and its imitation. Signs of bad strategy help recognize it.

  • Strategy delusion is a common confusion between real strategy and what only pretends to be strategy
  • The illusion arises when a grand, "fluffy" vision or ambitious goals are taken for a coherent plan
  • Real strategy requires hard choices: giving up many good ideas in favor of the best ones
  • Bad strategy tries to please everyone and in the end achieves nothing
  • Four red flags of bad strategy: fluff, failure to face the challenge, mistaking goals for strategy, and bad strategic objectives (laundry list)

The Kernel of a Good Strategy

The kernel of a good strategy is a simple logical structure of three elements: a diagnosis, a guiding policy, and coherent actions.

  • The kernel of a good strategy, according to Rumelt, is a simple framework and an antidote to "fluff" (bombastic, empty rhetoric)
  • A good strategy is not a hundred-and-ten-page document, but coherent actions supported by clear reasoning
  • The three parts of the kernel: diagnosis (identifying the essence of the situation), guiding policy (the overall approach), and coherent actions (specific, coordinated steps)
  • Analogy: a doctor who makes a diagnosis, then chooses an approach to treatment and prescribes specific procedures

Example: Apple's Turnaround

Пример Apple в 1997 году показывает, как работает ядро стратегии: диагноз хаоса, сведение всего к фокусу и радикальное упрощение.

  • In 1997, Apple was on the brink of bankruptcy, producing dozens of products, running several operating systems, and dispersing its resources
  • Steve Jobs diagnosed the root cause as a paralyzing lack of focus, not low sales or profits, which were only symptoms
  • Guiding policy: concentrate all energy and talent on a small number of products and make them "insanely great"
  • Coherent actions: cut the product line to roughly four products and abandon printers and other peripheral devices
  • This focused approach laid the foundation for the iPod, iPhone, and Apple's rise to become the most valuable company in the world

Key Takeaways and Comparison

A good strategy is a way of thinking, not a template. Its essence is choosing and focusing limited resources.

  • A good strategy is not filling in a template or using the right corporate buzzwords, but a way of thinking
  • Comparison: a bad strategy avoids hard choices, while a good one makes a decision; a bad strategy is a wish list, while a good one is a coherent plan for overcoming obstacles
  • A good strategy offers a unique solution to a unique challenge, rather than copying competitors' actions
  • Strategy is choice: the clarity and courage to focus time, money, and energy on what matters most and deliberately give up the rest