~11m37:19
Алексей Шевцов

ФРАНЦИЯ НИЩАЯ СТРАНА

Nov 16, 2026

Read: ~11m · You save: 26 min

Is France a poor country?

Why is France, a symbol of luxury, losing its economic standing? Debt, pensions, protests, and a comparison with Mississippi and Czechia.

Introduction

The author of the article argues that the protests in France have primarily economic causes. The younger generation joined them later, and its demands are related to consumer goods. In the author's view, the root of the problem lies in the crisis of the social model that took shape after the Second World War.

Post-World War II Social Model

After the end of the war, France built a welfare state with an extensive system of benefits and pensions. Citizens receive free education and free medical care, and have the opportunity to retire very early. According to the author, the French pension is among the highest in the world.

The country ranks among the lowest in the number of working hours per week. Labor rights in France, according to the author, are among the most protected in the world. Influential trade unions have for decades fought for better working conditions, higher pensions, and higher wages.

The author describes the root cause of the protests as the breakdown of the "socially paternalistic contract." The essence of the contract is this: citizens give up a significant portion of their income in the form of taxes, and the state promises full support at every stage of life. These stages include birth, childhood, education, work, and retirement.

In the author's view, this model relied on borrowed money and on the account of other generations of French people. He quotes Margaret Thatcher: socialism is wonderful until other people's money runs out. In his assessment, in France that money is beginning to run out.

The «Glorious Thirty» Years of Growth

The French budget was last balanced in 1974. That same year marked the end of the period known as the «Glorious Thirty». Over three decades, the country's economy grew by an average of 5% per year, and by as much as 9% in some years. Over those 30 years, France's GDP grew 4.5 times.

Unemployment during that period did not exceed 3%. Today, according to the author, it exceeds 8%. Unemployment among those under 24 reaches 21%. The author attributes this to the policies of the socialist state.

The Marshall Plan and Industrialization

According to the author, the economic miracle began with American money. France received 20% of the funds under the Marshall Plan. Only Great Britain received more.

Rather than using these funds for social payments to win voters, as would be done today, the state directed them toward modernizing the economy and building infrastructure. Hydroelectric power plants and factories producing tractors and combine harvesters were built.

The author notes that by 1945 France was not a fully developed agrarian state. According to statistics, in 1945 France had one tractor for every 200 farmers, while in the USA there was one tractor for every 40 farmers. By the 1950s, the number of tractors had grown from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands. French farmers became a prosperous class. Later, according to the author, they used these tractors to dump manure on town hall buildings.

France also became an industrial power. Factories were converted to assembly lines based on American patents. Americans helped build enterprises using Henry Ford's methods. Thousands of managers and specialists from French factories trained at General Motors, Chrysler, and Ford. The USA supplied the country with equipment and assembly lines.

The author argues that the USA thereby repaid France for its help in the War of Independence against Great Britain. At that time, France sent instructors, weapons, and provisions. The author also specifically mentions Lafayette, in whose honor streets in New York and Paris are named.

The 1974 Oil Crisis and Nuclear Energy

Growth continued until 1974. Then the global oil crisis erupted. OPEC countries imposed an embargo, and oil prices quadrupled. The economy did not collapse, but the budget went into deficit for the first time, and, according to the author, the country has been unable to return to balance ever since.

The crisis forced France to seek alternative energy sources. The country began developing nuclear power. By the 1990s, France had become one of the largest exporters of electricity in Europe. According to the author, it earns billions of euros a year from selling electricity to Britain, Germany, and Italy.

State Capitalism

The author contrasts France's economic model with the US model. According to him, the US relied on the "invisible hand of the market," while France built state capitalism.

The state nationalized large companies: banks, power plants, railways, and airlines. Among them were Air France and the national rail carrier SNCF. The state became the main investor, chief regulator, and largest employer.

In the author's view, this model is effective when building power grids, railways, and hydroelectric power plants. In the post-industrial era, he claims, it is completely ineffective in the IT sector. This sector requires fast investment and prompt decisions, not slow centralized management.

The author gives two examples. The government tried to create its own competitor to IBM in the last century and failed. In the late 1970s, Minitel was created with state funding, a device that provided access to the network. It was provided to people for free, and only a subscription fee was charged. According to the author, the state protected this outdated technology, and as a result, the mass adoption of the global internet in the country was delayed by about ten years.

Венчурный капитал и банки

Автор утверждает, что государственный капитализм не позволил во Франции сформироваться культуре венчурного капитала. Все проходило через государство, поэтому крупные инвестиционные фонды не появились. Частные банки существовали, но финансировали консервативные отрасли, например промышленные предприятия. Они не были готовы рисковать и не финансировали интернет-компании в 1990-х годах, в отличие от американских банков.

Автор отвечает на довод, что интернет-компании потерпели крах при лопнувшем пузыре доткомов в 1990-х. По его словам, кризис уничтожил только слабейших и оставил сильнейших: Nvidia, Amazon, Google, eBay, PayPal и Netflix. Французских аналогов, по его утверждению, не возникло.

Вместо этого, по словам автора, во Франции сохранились старые убыточные предприятия, которым не позволяли обанкротиться. Он приводит пример одного из крупнейших французских банков. В 1990-х годах банк спекулировал на международных рынках, накопил крупные долги и был спасен государством на 20 млрд за счет налоговых поступлений. Автор утверждает, что в США такой банк обанкротился бы, а на его месте открылся бы другой. По его словам, Франция «всегда спасает тонущих», потому что эти люди составляют часть электората.

Автор утверждает, что основными последствиями стали две тенденции. Во-первых, молодые основатели стартапов массово уезжают в США и на Nasdaq, так как там можно получить крупный капитал. Во-вторых, профсоюзы фактически захватили предприятия стратегического значения. Забастовки на таких предприятиях, по его словам, парализуют работу всей страны. Государство вынуждено соглашаться с требованиями, в том числе с ранним выходом на пенсию для госслужащих и повышением их зарплат.

Debt and Budget

The author presents key indicators. The budget deficit amounts to 5.5% of GDP. This is significantly above the 3% threshold set by European budget discipline. According to his data, public debt has reached 120% of GDP. In 2001, this figure stood at 57%.

The author argues that budgetary chaos and political instability have caused investors to lose confidence in France. As a result, the country is forced to borrow money at high interest rates. In his words, France is borrowing at 4.5% per year, which is the highest level in the last 25 years.

The author notes that in 2001, interest rates on French loans were also higher than they are now. He explains this by the difference in the amount of debt. In his words, paying 5% of 300and5300 and 5% of 3,000 are different sums. In addition, in 2001 the economy was growing, the population was increasing, and there were fewer obligations.

According to the author, in 2015–2021 France was effectively receiving money almost for free: the interest rate on borrowing was minimal. In his words, these funds were directed not to infrastructure, schools, or scientific research, but to benefit and pension payments. According to the author, each new generation of politicians promised more and more.

The author presents the structure of expenditures. Pensions account for 24% of France's annual budget, or 15% of GDP. The entire social sector takes up 57% of the state budget, or more than 30% of GDP.

Comparison with Mississippi

The author compares France with the American state of Mississippi, which, in his words, is traditionally associated with poverty. According to his data, GDP per capita in Mississippi is 55,000,whereasinFranceitis55,000, whereas in France it is 46,000.

The author emphasizes the dynamics. In 2019, France was ahead of Mississippi, while in 2011 the gap was $10,000 in France's favor. In his view, if a country's economic indicators are lower than those of a state that leads American rankings of the worst regions, this is direct evidence of its decline.

External Debt and the Role of the Euro

The author compares the structure of government debt in the United States and France. In the US, most of the debt is owned by the country's own citizens: domestic hedge funds, pension funds, and private individuals. Foreigners hold 23%. In France the situation is reversed: more than 50% of the debt is held by foreign investors.

According to the author, a foreign investor can sell an asset and leave the country more quickly than a domestic one. He links this situation to France's membership in the eurozone. The euro made it easier for investors from Germany and the Netherlands to buy French assets. The author also notes that the US has its own printing press for the world's reserve currency. France uses the euro, which is issued by the European Central Bank (ECB).

The author claims that the ECB has stated that France must save itself. In his words, the ECB did this because financial chaos in France could become a very serious problem for the entire EU.

European Context

The author recalls the Greek debt crisis of 2010, which, in his words, nearly destroyed the euro. Greece's GDP accounts for only 2% of the EU's GDP. Saving this country required 300 billion euros.

France's GDP accounts for 16% of the EU's GDP. The author asks what would happen to France in the event of a crisis. In his view, France's financial, social, and political problems could fall on the shoulders of every European. All 27 EU countries, in his words, will pay for the pensions of French pensioners and the benefits of migrants from Algeria.

The author argues that France has moved from the status of "too big to fail" to the status of "too big to save." He does not take credit for this formulation. France's public debt exceeds 3 trillion euros.

Europe has the European Stability Mechanism, created to support EU economies during difficult times. According to the author, its budget is 500 billion dollars. He notes that France itself contributes 20% of this budget. In his assessment, Greece can be saved, but France cannot.

Debt Servicing Costs

According to the author, in 2025 France spent 51 billion euros on interest payments on its debt. In 2026, spending had already exceeded 60 billion euros, and the year has not yet ended. The government forecasts that in 2027 interest expenses will amount to 90 billion euros. The author emphasizes that this refers only to interest, without repayment of the principal debt.

The author argues that these funds could have gone to infrastructure and education. He cites the example of schools without air conditioning or heating, which, in his words, became one of the causes of student protests. According to the author, France spends 5% of GDP on education. By forecast, by 2030 debt servicing costs will amount to 3.7%. The author sums up: France is paying for the election promises of past years at the expense of its future.

Ratings and Comparison with Italy

The author argues that investors rate France so low that interest rates on its borrowing are higher than those for Greece or Italy. According to him, 15 years ago no one would have believed that Italy would enjoy greater trust from lenders than France.

According to the author, Italy demonstrates better budget discipline and has a budget surplus. Its revenues exceed its expenditures excluding debt servicing. France, in his words, still runs a budget deficit even excluding public debt.

The author also cites an example of how funds are allocated within the budget. He claims that 30% of the Ministry of Education's budget goes not to education but to pensions. The government, in his words, collects funds from various ministries to support one population group.

Pension Reform

According to the author, France needs a pension reform. The OECD, he says, takes the same position. The reform involves raising the retirement age. Emmanuel Macron tried to push it through, and protests broke out in the streets.

The author argues that the budget situation is so dire that the government was forced to ignore the protests and push the reform through. However, he says, France remains a democratic country. That is why in 2025 the reform was softened for the sake of political survival. For some groups of citizens, the retirement age was postponed by three months.

The author cites the demands of a coalition of five French trade unions. The first demand is higher wages. The second is even greater growth in pensions. The fourth is an increase in the minimum wage. In the final point, he says, it is proposed to raise taxes on the wealthy and increase inheritance taxes.

The author claims that protest participants march with USSR flags and demand more socialist reforms, benefits, and spending. In his view, it is precisely this policy of the last 30 years that brought the country to its current situation.

The author believes that spending more is no longer possible. In terms of social spending, he says, according to his data, France in Europe ranks second only to Denmark. He notes that the Danish model is unique and cannot be reproduced in other countries. Earlier, the author devoted a separate video to Danish socialism.

The author describes a conflict between generations. Money, he says, is being taken from schools and directed to pensioners. Pensioners and students nevertheless take to the streets together, even though they effectively compete for one limited resource: money. According to the author, the state is forced to choose who receives it. The left, he claims, offers only one answer to the question of where the funds should come from: raise taxes on the wealthy.

Taxes and Inheritance

The author argues that France already has one of the highest inheritance taxes in the world. The tax-free threshold is 100,000 euros. The amount above the threshold is taxed on a progressive scale from 5% to 45%. As an example, the author cites an apartment worth 300,000 euros. This refers to an unrenovated one-room apartment in Paris, which, according to the author's assumption, was bought in the 1950s, when it cost significantly less. The tax on such an apartment would be 40,000 euros. If the heirs do not have these funds, the property must be sold. The author considers this arrangement robbery, since VAT was paid at the time of purchase. By his data, inheritance taxes are higher only in Belgium and Spain. The author notes that these countries are unlikely to be considered role models.

In his words, truly wealthy French people find many ways to reduce their tax payments. The main taxpayers remain members of the middle class, who spent their whole lives earning enough for one apartment.

The author objects to the idea of taxing the rich. According to the OECD, France regularly ranks first or second in the ratio of taxes to GDP. The maximum income tax rate in the country is 45%, plus an additional 4% "super tax" on high incomes. Social insurance contributions are also added. In total, the combined tax burden can reach 60%.

The author claims that no business will pay such a rate. It will either go underground or leave the country. In his words, this is exactly what has been happening to French business in recent years. Over two decades, the tax on large fortunes has led to the departure of thousands of millionaires. The most famous example, according to the author, is actor Gérard Depardieu, who first moved to Belgium. This happened when the government of François Hollande proposed a 75% rate on income above 1 million euros per year.

The author claims that the left does not take into account the possibility of the wealthy leaving. They change their jurisdiction, move to the UAE, where there are no taxes, or to the United States. The poor and the middle class, in his words, cannot leave, and the tax burden will fall on them.

The author gives a hypothetical example involving Bernard Arnault. If he left France, he would lose only a small part of his fortune. But those who work in his boutiques and factories would suffer, since they would lose their jobs. Moreover, according to the author, high taxes on the rich would not bring significant revenue to the budget.

The author cites a study by the French Economic Institute. According to his data, closing the tax loopholes used by the super-rich would bring the state 5.5 billion euros per year. This is less than 4% of the annual deficit, which amounts to 152 billion euros. The total public debt, by his data, is 3.5 trillion euros.

The author also argues that under tax pressure, some citizens leave. In his words, no business will pay 70%, as the left proposes. The outflow of technology specialists is, in the author's view, especially dangerous. Programmers and startup founders are moving to the United States, where taxes are lower, regulation is lighter, and there are no, as he puts it, intrusive trade unions. In his words, this is precisely why France has stopped creating products that the world uses.

The author asks rhetorical questions: name a French app that you use, and does France have any goods besides Chanel perfume and Louis Vuitton bags. He allows that even these goods may be made in China. In his view, implementing the demands of the protesters will push France even deeper into an industrial and technological crisis. The country, in his words, has stopped creating competitive products.

Labor Productivity

The author calls stagnation of labor productivity the most important problem. In his view, the system can afford better working conditions, pensions, and wages only if it produces the most competitive products in the world. Such products must have very high added value. The author gives an example: a worker may work six hours a day while producing a product worth tens of thousands of euros.

To create such products, according to the author, the country needs to invest in scientific research and development, universities, and education. The country must become a center of attraction for talent from around the world. Instead, the author claims, France has become a center for the inflow of migrants from Algeria and Tunisia. Others, in his words, have to go through "visa hell" before they can enter the country and bring money and knowledge. The author considers France a beautiful country that is nonetheless closed to intellect and capital.

Demography and the Pension System

The author notes that in the 1960s, when France's socialist model was taking shape, there were almost five working people for every pensioner. In his words, five people can easily split the bill for one person at a restaurant. Today there are fewer than two working people for every pensioner. The author says that young French people are, in effect, paying for the pensioner alone.

The author names three causes of the crisis. The first is demography. According to the author, France's birth rate is below two. The population has stopped reproducing itself, and mass migration, in his view, has not solved this problem and has only increased the number of citizens who must be supported through taxes. The second, in his assessment, more important cause is the improvement in medical care, thanks to which the French have begun to live longer. The third cause, in his words, is compounded by the first two.

The author argues that the French pension system is pay-as-you-go rather than funded. It depends directly on demographics. A working young person pays a tax, and that money goes immediately to the current pensioner. In the Netherlands, according to the author, pension funds invest money in shares and bonds. Pensions there are largely financed by income from accumulated assets rather than by direct contributions, as in France. In the author's view, this is what allows the Dutch to cope more easily with the demographic shift.

The author acknowledges that France's pension fund also invests, but a far smaller share of its receipts. Most of the money the country pays out immediately, "so that the streets don't burn." The author notes that the reference to burning streets obstructs necessary reforms. Reforms whose effects appear only after decades cost politicians their political future. The results come decades later, and the success will be credited to a different generation of politicians.

In the author's view, France's pension system cannot be changed painlessly. Voters' anger, in his words, is understandable: in their youth, they paid for the pensions. The author considers the pension system a real swindle. A person pays contributions throughout their working life, and only a small part of that money is returned by the state.

The author concedes that this system has undermined the birth rate, since children used to provide for old age, whereas today, as he puts it, the state presumably does this instead. He notes that Generation Z around the world understands that state pensions cannot be relied upon. In his view, people from the post-Soviet space have it easier in this respect, since they never had any initial hope in the state. They were raised with the conviction that the state will always deceive them. At the same time, in the author's words, the Soviet state never collected from its citizens taxes like those the French state collected from the French, and it never seriously promised anything.

Labor Market and Labor Legislation

The author describes the difficulties of hiring and firing in France. According to him, an employer can dismiss an employee only with an impeccable legal justification. If the reason is poorly documented, the employee turns to a trade union and files a wrongful dismissal lawsuit. According to the author, the penalties amount to three to 20 months of the employee's salary. He claims that courts overwhelmingly side with the employee.

The author gives the example of an acquaintance, a French citizen who works at Apple in Paris. A year ago he was effectively dismissed, but without any formal termination. The company has been paying him a monthly medical allowance of 300 euros for a year, although he did not have a permanent employment contract. With a permanent contract, according to the author, he would have been paid compensation of several months' salary. In some cases, employees receive compensation equal to an annual salary.

The author argues that employers, knowing how difficult it is to dismiss someone, use loopholes. One of them is the maximum probationary period of eight months. According to the author, after the probationary period an employer can state that the employee is not suitable, and this cannot be challenged. Previously, he says, a Frenchman could be hired and, if things didn't work out, quietly let go, after which he would quickly find another job. Now, he says, for eight months a person works for the minimum wage or receives nothing, with no guarantee of steady work.

Another loophole is the fixed-term employment contract (CDD) lasting six months. According to the author, young people in France move from one short-term contract to another for years, without any stable prospect for the future.

The author claims that without a permanent contract, young people cannot obtain a loan, a mortgage, or rent an apartment. A landlord, he says, needs such a contract as a minimal guarantee of solvency. The law, originally intended to protect tenants, according to the author, does not allow the eviction of a non-paying tenant, especially in winter.

The author believes that this system has turned people's lives into hell. According to him, a similar situation has developed in Spain, but in the real estate market. To protect poor mothers from eviction, landlords were obliged to fulfill numerous obligations. As a result, according to the author, in Spain today it is impossible to rent an apartment even if you have the money and are willing to pay a year in advance. He cites the example of Barcelona, where a 30 square meter apartment is offered for 2,000 euros a month.

The author also gives an example from Germany. His subscriber works at a large German company and encountered a similar attitude toward employees. An employee systematically stole food from the office kitchen, taking chocolate bars by the pack. He received three warnings. After that, he was dismissed. He received a severance payment of 22,000 euros. Initially he demanded 50,000 euros, but, according to the author, the amount was reduced to 20,000 euros in court.

The author asks how a company can develop under such conditions. He believes that supporters of this system do not understand that it becomes a barrier for young people looking for work. According to him, this is now the era of fast startups and fast business. In the US, he says, a startup can lay off 80% of its staff in one day, hire 80% new employees, and keep operating. In France, according to the author, this is impossible: the company would be dragged into court. People laid off in the US, he claims, quickly find new jobs, because employers there are more willing to hire.

Paris and the Protests

The author argues that protests in France have a long tradition and are part of the national identity. He acknowledges that this is partly true. The modern appearance of Paris, in his words, was entirely created by Baron Haussmann, who designed the city so that protesters would find it harder to erect barricades. Wide boulevards and large squares, in his view, were created precisely for this purpose. The author also notes that Paris has historically burned, but previously the French burned it for France, whereas today, in his words, it is second-generation migrants holding French passports who are doing so for Palestine.

The author notes a change in the composition of protesters. Previously, even the most far-left communist protests, in his words, included French tricolors. Today, there are almost none at rallies. Instead, in his observation, flags of Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, and Palestine are visible. The author claims that anti-imperialist rhetoric, which, in his words, was imposed by the "Muslim Brotherhood," is now being heard in Europe. The protesters of the past, in his opinion, were concerned exclusively with the economy, whereas today, in his words, they are preoccupied with defining what France is.

The author claims that from the French Revolution to the mass rallies of 1968, protesters carried the tricolor, whereas today, in his words, the French openly feel ashamed of the national flag. In his assessment, the left of that time did not experience a hyperbolized guilt complex over the colonies. Today, in the author's words, this complex is imposed on every young Frenchman from the first day of school. The author compares this to Christianity: in his words, a person born in France finds himself guilty before a dozen former colonies. Young French people with whom the author spoke personally sincerely believe that they must pay and repent for the deeds of their ancestors. According to him, they are indeed paying: millions of people from the former colonies have come to France to use social services. At the same time, in the author's words, no one at contemporary rallies speaks out against this segment of the population.

The author shares observations about Parisian landmarks. According to him, Paris has a small Kiev Square and a view from its benches of Alexander III Bridge. He also mentions the Winston Churchill monument. The author calls this French sense of humor. He notes that public schools in the West raise people who hate the state as such, rather than a specific political regime.

The author gives an example of vandalism. The statue of Marianne, the allegorical symbol of France, was defaced. The author considers this an insult not to a historical figure, but to the republic itself and its democracy. In his words, a local Parisian school evidently does not support Macron, but respects communism and the "Antifa" movement.

The author also describes the state of the city after the protests. According to him, he arrives in Paris almost immediately after the protests end, and each time he is struck by the speed of the cleanup. Apart from closed boutique shop windows, in his words, almost nothing remains. There are many boarded-up windows, but there is almost no destruction, debris, or broken glass. The author highly praises the work of the municipal services and concludes that taxes, in his opinion, go where they should.

The author shows the damage at another site. Paving stones were torn up and used to smash windows, storefronts, and cars. Therefore, in his words, this area has still not been restored.

Conclusion

The author argues that what is happening in France represents the collapse of the welfare state system. The economic model built after World War II, in his words, failed to account for declining birth rates and rising borrowing costs. Now, in his assessment, the French do not know what to do.

The author reminds us that France has already experienced a crisis like this. In 1789, in his words, 50% of the state treasury went to paying off debts, while the local population, in his claim, was starving. This happened on the eve of the French Revolution.

Introduction: The Debt Illusion and the Reason for Protests

The author explains that visible wealth can hide debts. The example of one million euros against a debt of one and a half million shows that the person has no real equity.

  • If a person has 1 million euros but owes 1.5 million for a building, they have no money of their own
  • Failure to pay on time leads to bankruptcy
  • The million was taken at an exorbitant interest rate to repay past debts
  • Large interest payments are made daily while the loan remains in effect
  • Protests in France began for economic reasons, not because of immigration

The Socialist Contract and the Welfare State

After World War II, France built a welfare state. The social contract called for high taxes in exchange for support at every stage of life, but it relied on borrowing and on other generations.

  • After World War II, France built a welfare state
  • Free education and healthcare, very early retirement, and one of the highest pensions in the world
  • France ranks last in the number of working hours per week
  • Labor rights are among the most protected in the world; trade unions fought for better conditions, pensions, and wages
  • Citizens give a significant share of their income in taxes in exchange for support at birth, during education, at work, and in retirement
  • The author quotes Margaret Thatcher: socialism is wonderful until other people's money runs out

Post-War Economic Boom

During the "Glorious Thirty" (1945–1974), France's economy grew rapidly thanks to American aid, industrialization, and agricultural modernization.

  • France's last balanced budget was in 1974, which coincided with the end of the "Glorious Thirty"
  • Economic growth averaged 5% per year, reaching up to 9% in some years
  • GDP grew 4.5 times over 30 years
  • Unemployment did not exceed 3%; now it is above 8%, and among youth under 24 it reaches 21%
  • France received 20% of the Marshall Plan, and only Great Britain received more
  • The money was directed to hydroelectric power stations and tractor and combine harvester factories, rather than to social payments for votes
  • In 1945, there was one tractor for every 200 farmers in France, while in the USA there was one tractor for every 40 farmers
  • By the 1950s, the tractor fleet grew from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands
  • French specialists trained at General Motors, Chrysler, and Ford factories, and Henry Ford's methods were applied
  • The author mentions that France helped the USA in the War of Independence, and Lafayette became a symbol of this assistance

Oil Crisis and Nuclear Energy

The 1974 oil crisis caused a budget deficit that France failed to overcome. The response was the development of nuclear energy, which later made the country a major electricity exporter.

  • Global oil crisis of 1974: OPEC embargo, oil prices quadrupled
  • The economy did not collapse, but the budget went into deficit for the first time, and France has not recovered since then
  • The crisis forced a search for alternative energy sources, and France began developing nuclear power
  • By the 1990s, France had become one of the largest electricity exporters in Europe
  • France earns billions of euros per year by selling electricity to the United Kingdom, Germany, and Italy

State Capitalism and Technological Lag

France chose state capitalism rather than the US market model. This held back the development of venture financing and the IT sector, and state projects such as Minitel could not compete.

  • The US relied on the "invisible hand of the market", while France built state capitalism
  • The state nationalized banks, energy, railways, and airlines, such as Air France and SNCF
  • The state became the main investor, regulator, and employer
  • State capitalism is effective for power grids and railways, but ineffective in the post-industrial IT era
  • An attempt to create a competitor to IBM failed
  • In the late 1970s the state launched Minitel, which was given away free in exchange for a subscription fee, but because of this the adoption of the global internet was delayed by roughly a decade
  • Due to state control, a culture of venture capital did not form; private banks financed conservative industries rather than startups
  • During the dot-com bubble, Nvidia, Amazon, Google, eBay, PayPal, and Netflix survived, while nothing comparable emerged in France
  • Ha

Unions, Labor Market, and Rigid Labor Laws

Strong unions and state-owned companies have led to strikes, concessions, and restrictions on the labor market. Because of rigid labor laws, young people face difficulties finding jobs and housing.

  • One of France's largest banks took risks in international markets in the 1990s and was rescued by the state with 20 billion euros of taxpayer money
  • In the US, such a bank would have gone bankrupt, and another would have opened in its place
  • French startup founders leave for the US and Nasdaq because in France they face taxes and fines
  • According to the author, strategic companies are captured by unions, and strikes paralyze the country
  • The state gave in to demands: early retirement and higher salaries for civil servants
  • The probationary period has been stretched to the maximum of eight months
  • Fixed-term CDD contracts of six months mean young people change jobs for years
  • Without a permanent contract, it is hard to get a loan, a mortgage, or a rental apartment
  • Fines for unfair dismissal amount to three to 20 months of salary, and courts more often side with the employee
  • An example of a friend working at Apple in Paris: the company pays him 300 euros a month in medical benefits for a year
  • In Germany, an employee who stole snacks from the office was fired after three warnings and received a severance payment of 22,000 euros (he demanded 50,000)
  • In the US, a startup can fire 80% of its employees in a day and hire new ones, while in France this is impossible due to the courts

Comparison with Mississippi and the Czech Republic

The author compares France with the American state of Mississippi and with the Czech Republic. By GDP per capita, France falls behind Mississippi, while the Czech Republic has lower debt, unemployment, and deficit.

  • GDP per capita in Mississippi is about 55,000,whileinFranceitisabout55,000, while in France it is about 46,000
  • In 2019 France was ahead of Mississippi, and in 2011 it led by $10,000
  • Mississippi is traditionally considered one of the poorest US states
  • The Czech Republic's government debt is nearly three times lower than France's, unemployment is three times lower, and the budget deficit is half as large
  • The author promotes the opportunity for a scholarship in the Czech Republic, but the advertising segment is excluded from the summary

Government Debt, Interest Rates and Risks for Europe

France's budget deficit and public debt are rising, and interest rates on borrowing are higher than before. A significant share of the debt is held by foreigners, which increases risks. Interest expenses are growing, and the ECB is concerned about the situation.

  • France's budget deficit is 5.5% of GDP, against the European standard of 3%
  • France borrows money at 4.5%, the highest rate in 25 years
  • In 2001 rates were higher, but public debt was 57% of GDP, now it is 120%
  • From 2015 to 2021 France effectively received money almost for free and spent it on social payments
  • 24% of France's annual budget goes to pensions, which is 15% of GDP
  • The entire social sphere accounts for 57% of the state budget, or more than 30% of GDP
  • In the US, debt is mostly owned by Americans, with foreigners holding about 23%, while in France it is more than 50%
  • France joined the eurozone, which made it easier for investors from Germany and the Netherlands to buy its assets
  • The ECB stated that France must save itself, since financial chaos could become a problem for the entire EU
  • The Greek crisis of 2010 nearly destroyed the euro; Greece accounts for 2% of EU GDP, and its rescue required 300 billion euros
  • France's economy makes up 16% of EU GDP, and its public debt exceeds 3 trillion euros
  • The European Stability Mechanism has a budget of 500 billion dollars, 20% of which is contributed by France itself
  • France's debt servicing costs: 51 billion euros in 2025, more than 60 billion in 2026, and a forecast of 90 billion euros in 2027
  • France spends about 5% of GDP on education, and by 2030 debt servicing costs are estimated at 3.7% of GDP
  • Interest rates on French loans are higher than those of Greece and Italy
  • Italy's budget is in surplus, while France's budget is in deficit even excluding public debt
  • 30% of the Ministry of Education's budget goes to pensions

Pension reform and protesters' demands

The pension reform, initiated by Macron and supported by the OECD, has triggered protests. Trade unions demand higher wages and pensions, but propose raising taxes on the wealthy.

  • The OECD believes France needs a pension reform, including raising the retirement age
  • The reform was softened in 2025: for some groups, retirement is possible 3 months earlier
  • Pensions and education compete for one limited resource: money
  • France's social spending is surpassed only by Denmark's
  • A trade union alliance of five unions demands higher wages, pensions, and a minimum wage
  • The left proposes raising taxes on the wealthy and inheritance taxes

Taxes, the Rich and Emigration

France has high inheritance and income taxes. The author considers them unfair to the middle class and argues that the wealthy are leaving while tax revenues are not growing.

  • The inheritance tax-free threshold is €100,000; above it, a progressive scale applies from 5% to 45%
  • Example: an apartment in Paris worth €300,000, with tax of €40,000
  • The maximum income tax rate is 45%, plus an additional 4% surtax, plus contributions, for a total burden of up to 60%
  • France ranks first or second in the OECD by share of taxes in GDP
  • Actor Gérard Depardieu moved to Belgium
  • Under Hollande, a 75% tax on income above €1 million per year was proposed
  • Study by the French Economic Institute: closing loopholes would yield €5.5 billion per year, which is less than 4% of the deficit
  • Annual deficit of €152 billion, public debt of €3.5 trillion
  • The author believes that high taxes hurt workers rather than capital owners

Demographics and the Pension System

Demographics and the pay-as-you-go pension model make the system vulnerable. In the Netherlands, the pension fund invests, while in France the money is paid out to pensioners immediately.

  • In the 1960s there were about five workers per pensioner, now fewer than two
  • The birth rate is below two, and immigration has not solved the problem
  • Causes of the crisis: demographics, rising life expectancy, and the distributive system
  • The French pension system is distributive, not funded
  • In the Netherlands, the pension fund invests assets in stocks and bonds
  • The author calls the pension system a scam, since the state returns only a small part of contributions

Protests, Paris, and Cultural Heritage

The author observes the aftermath of protests in Paris, compares the city with the situation in Spain and Germany, and reflects on cultural heritage and street protests.

  • Baron Haussmann rebuilt Paris so that it became harder to erect barricades
  • Protesters today wave flags of Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, and Palestine rather than the tricolor
  • The Marianne monument has been damaged, which the author considers an insult to the republic
  • Paris is quickly cleaned up after protests, though broken shop windows remain
  • In Spain, rent regulation makes it difficult to rent housing; in Barcelona, a 30 m² apartment is rented for 2000 euros per month

Conclusion

The author concludes that the French welfare state is collapsing due to demographics, rising debt, and expensive credit. The economic model of the postwar period did not account for these factors.

  • The model built after World War II did not account for falling birth rates and rising borrowing costs
  • Historical example: in 1789, half of the treasury went to paying debts while the population starved
  • The French Revolution began in 1789