~9m20:51
Golden Editorial

15 Edits I’m Tired of Making on Your Book

Nov 17, 2026

Read: ~9m · You save: 12 min

15 Edits I'm Tired of Making on Your Book

Think your manuscript is clean? Discover 15 common self-editing mistakes, from echo words and filter words to head hopping, that editors spot in the first few pages.

A manuscript may feel clean to its author and still contain errors that an editor flags within the first few pages. A writer can catch each of the following 15 issues during self-editing. Their presence does not indicate poor writing, since nearly every first draft contains them. However, uncorrected errors cause editors to spend time on line-level cleanup rather than on the structural and craft problems that require professional attention.

1. Redundancies

A redundancy is a word that repeats meaning already present in the same sentence. Examples include "nodded her head," "shrugged his shoulders," and "whispered quietly." Redundancies tend to cluster, so a writer who finds one often finds others throughout the manuscript.

  • Method: For every modifier, check whether the verb already covers its meaning. A shrug already involves shoulders, and a whisper already involves quiet.
  • Search terms: "head," "shoulders," "quietly," and similar words.
  • Nonfiction examples: "past history" and "end result."
  • Exception: "Stood up" and "sat down" are redundant, but editors often remove "up" and "down" only to streamline prose. Individual instances rarely distract readers. Revising them makes sense only when the pattern recurs throughout the book.

2. Crutch Words

Crutch words are personal words or gestures that a writer uses so often that they lose meaning. Common examples include "just," "really," "actually," "suddenly," and "honestly." Gestures such as "smirked" or "sighed" can function the same way. Because each writer's crutches differ, generic word lists miss them.

  • Method: Paste a chapter into a free word frequency counter, or use Copilot in Word, which analyzes text without changing it. Ignore common function words such as "the" and "and," and review any word that appears more often than its role justifies.
  • Alternative method: Search for individual words in the word processor to count occurrences.
  • Exception: A crutch word that does character or narrative work, such as a character's repeated phrase, should remain. Authorial voice consists of deliberate choices, not unintended repetition.

3. Echo Words

An echo word is a noticeable word that appears twice within a few lines without intent. Echoes are easier to hear than to see.

  • Method: Use read-aloud in Word or a text-to-speech program, and mark each echo as it occurs.
  • Fix: Replace one of the two instances, usually the second. For example, "dim hallway" becomes "narrow hallway," or the adjective is removed.
  • Exclusions: Common words such as "said" and character names do not count. Repetition used deliberately for rhythm or emphasis should remain.

4. Stock Phrases

Stock phrases are pre-written descriptions that writers absorb from reading. Examples include "a shiver ran down her spine," "his heart pounded in his chest," and "she let out a breath she didn't know she was holding." Readers recognize these phrases quickly, so they reduce the impact of key emotional moments.

  • Method: Read the first half of a phrase aloud to another person. If the listener can finish it, the phrase is a cliché.
  • Fix: Describe what this specific character's body does in this specific moment. For example, a character who has just survived a scare might sit down on the bottom step and remain there.

5. Hedging

Hedging softens statements that do not require softening. Examples include "sort of," "seemed a little," "could be argued," and "may." Multiple hedges make the narrator sound uncertain about the story itself.

  • Search terms: "seemed," "sort of," "kind of," "a little," "somewhat," "almost," and "perhaps."
  • Method: For each instance, ask whose uncertainty it expresses. If a point-of-view character cannot know the fact, the hedge may remain. If the writer avoids commitment, remove it.
  • Example: In close third person from Aaron's point of view, "Aaron seemed a little nervous" fails because Aaron knows whether he is nervous. In Austin's point of view, watching her from across a table, "seemed" is accurate because he must infer her state.
  • Nonfiction: If evidence is mixed, state that once and plainly. If evidence is not mixed, remove the hedge and make the claim.

6. Filter Words

Filter words are perception verbs such as "saw," "heard," "felt," "noticed," "realized," "watched," "could see," and "could hear." They place a character between the reader and the event.

  • Example: "Hannah heard the front door slam" becomes "The front door slammed."
  • Method: Search for each filter word, delete it, and reread the sentence. If the sentence still works, keep the deletion.
  • Exceptions: Keep a filter when the act of noticing is the point, as in "It was an hour before Hannah noticed the keys were gone." Keep a filter when the character may be wrong, as in "She thought she heard the door," because the doubt depends on the filter.

7. Filler Words

Filler words add length without adding meaning.

  • Example: "There was a dog that started to bark in order to warn them" (13 words) becomes "A dog barked a warning" (5 words).
  • Search terms: "started to" and "began to." Keep them only when the action is interrupted, as in "Tony started to answer, and she cut him off." Elsewhere, state the action directly: "She started to walk to the door" becomes "She walked to the door."
  • "That": Test each instance by removing it. If the sentence reads the same, delete it. For example, "He knew that she was lying" becomes "He knew she was lying." Do not use find-and-replace to remove every "that," because some sentences require it.

8. Over-Explaining

Over-explaining states what a previous line or action already conveyed. For example, after "Kate slammed the door," the sentence "She was furious with him" repeats the information.

  • Dialogue: A character who says, "You've lived in this town your whole life. You know how people talk," gives the reader information the character already has. Remove such lines, or introduce the information through another method, such as a newcomer asking a question or a detail emerging during a conflict.
  • Method (fiction): Highlight every sentence that follows a line of dialogue or action and interprets it. Cover each highlighted sentence and ask whether the reader would still understand. If so, delete it.
  • Method (nonfiction): Read only the first sentence of each paragraph in a chapter. If two paragraphs make the same point, one can likely be cut.

9. Head-Hopping

Head-hopping occurs when a scene shifts between characters' thoughts without a marked transition. This is a story-level problem, and the fix may require rewriting the scene's point of view rather than changing a single sentence.

  • Example: "Aaron wondered if he could tell she'd been crying. Austin thought she looked tired and he hated that he noticed." The reader cannot tell which character is observing.
  • Method: Use two highlighter colors. Mark thoughts and feelings belonging to one main character in one color and those belonging to another character in the second color. A scene containing both colors without a scene break contains head-hopping.
  • Fix: Rewrite the second character from the outside, using only what the point-of-view character can see or hear. For example, "Austin looked at her a beat too long."
  • Omniscient point of view: Omniscient narration moves between heads deliberately, with a consistent narrative voice above the characters. It is less common today because many readers and writers prefer first person or close third person, which create intimate emotional access. Omniscient narration is also harder to execute well. Head-hopping differs from omniscient narration because it is close third person that slips.

10. Named Emotions

Naming an emotion gives the reader a label instead of an experience. "Nicole was nervous about the interview" states the emotion directly. By contrast, "Nicole read the address off her phone, put the phone away, and took it right back out to read it again" conveys nervousness through behavior.

  • Method: Search for emotion words such as "angry," "nervous," "scared," "relieved," "embarrassed," and "frustrated." For each, identify what the character does or says that would let a reader infer the feeling. Write that action and delete the label.
  • Exception: Naming an emotion is appropriate when the feeling is not the focus, especially during quick transitions where the narrative must move forward.

11. Walls of Text

A wall of text is a page of solid, unbroken paragraphs. It can be identified by zooming out until several pages are visible.

  • Problem: Dense paragraphs slow fast scenes, including fight scenes. A paragraph that combines dialogue, reaction, and description forces readers to work out who said what.
  • Rule: Start a new paragraph whenever the speaker changes.
  • Additional guidance: Break paragraphs when the scene's focus shifts, such as from an argument to the rain outside.
  • Formatting note: Printed book pages are smaller than standard document pages. A layout that looks acceptable on a laptop can appear as dense gray pages in print.
  • Exception: Long paragraphs suit slow, reflective passages. The test is whether the content of the paragraph belongs in the scene.

12. Tense Slips

A tense slip occurs when a sentence shifts tense unintentionally, as in "She walks into the kitchen and grabbed a mug." Writers often miss these errors during rereading.

  • Method (past tense manuscripts): Search for present-tense forms of common verbs, such as "says," "walks," "looks," and "turns." Any match outside dialogue is likely a slip.
  • Method (present tense manuscripts): Search for past-tense forms, such as "said" and "walked."
  • Flashbacks: In past-tense writing, use the past perfect ("had") to signal a move into the past. Use one or two instances of "had" to enter the flashback, then shift to simple past for the scene. Use one more "had" to return to the present. Avoid omitting "had" entirely, which blurs the time shift, and avoid applying "had" to every verb, which becomes clumsy.
  • Example: "Tony had met her at a wedding. He'd spilled wine on her shoes. She laughed it off and asked him to dance. That had been before the divorce."
  • Exception: Dialogue remains in the tense the character would use. "I hate this town," she said, uses present tense inside a past-tense manuscript, and this is correct.

13. Fancy Dialogue Tags

Fancy dialogue tags, such as "hissed," "exclaimed," "retorted," "chortled," and "interjected," draw attention away from the dialogue. Many of these verbs describe actions that speech cannot physically perform.

  • Example: "Don't go," she hissed. Speech does not hiss in this sentence, so the tag is inaccurate.
  • Fix: Replace the tag with an action beat or with "said." For example: "He scoffed. That's not what I meant." Here, the scoff is a separate action, and the reader's attention stays on the line.
  • Method: Search for every tag other than "said" or "asked." For each, check whether the words already convey the tone. If they do, change the tag to "said." If they do not, revise the line so that its intent is clear.
  • Exceptions: "Whispered" and "shouted" describe volume, which the words cannot convey alone, so they may remain.

14. Over-Tagging

Over-tagging means attaching a dialogue tag to every line. When only two characters speak, readers can follow the exchange without repeated tags.

  • Method: Copy a two-person conversation, delete all tags and names, and give the text to a reader who has not seen the manuscript. Ask that reader to identify the speaker of each line. Add a tag wherever the reader guesses incorrectly. Add a tag after a long passage of narration so readers do not lose their place.
  • Names: Characters who repeatedly address each other by name sound unnatural. Real conversations use names rarely.
  • Three or more speakers: When a scene includes three or more characters, more tags become necessary. Use a variety of tags and actions, with only one per line of dialogue.

15. Continuity Errors

Continuity errors are inconsistencies in facts, such as a character's eye color changing between chapters, a name spelled in multiple ways, a day of the week that changes without an intervening night, or a character sitting down twice without standing.

  • Method: Maintain a style sheet that records every fixed fact: the spelling of each character's name, ages, eye color, other physical details, possessions, and vehicles. At the top of each chapter, note the day and approximate time. Check each new detail against the sheet.
  • Physical tracking: Read a scene while tracking only the position of each character and the objects they hold. An object picked up in one paragraph must be placed somewhere before the next action that depends on it.
  • Note: Copy editors routinely find continuity errors even after careful self-editing. Reducing these errors during self-editing allows the editor's time to focus on problems that the writer cannot identify independently.

Applying the Self-Edit

Each of the 15 issues can be found through targeted searches or deliberate rereading. Reading for story tends to hide these errors because the reader's mind supplies the intended meaning. Addressing them one at a time, in separate passes, makes them easier to find.

Self-editing is a required stage of manuscript preparation. Most first drafts require substantial rewriting and revision. The self-edit precedes feedback from alpha and beta readers, decisions about the type of editing the manuscript needs, consideration of the publishing path, and work with a professional book editor.

Introduction

Self-editing catches problems so an editor's time goes to craft issues rather than cleanup. None of the 15 issues mean the writer is bad; all first drafts contain them.

  • Editor can spot within the first few pages whether a writer has self-edited or sent a first draft
  • There are 15 notes the editor leaves on almost every manuscript
  • Paying an editor for fixes you could make yourself wastes money and distracts from craft problems

1. Redundancies

Redundancies are words that repeat what another word in the sentence already conveys, such as nodded her head or shrugged his shoulders. Cut the extra word and reread.

  • Examples: nodded her head, shrugged his shoulders, whispered quietly
  • Other examples: blink, snap, point; nonfiction favorites are past history and end result
  • Search for her head, his head, shoulders, and quietly
  • Exception: stood up and sat down, which the editor prefers to trim to simplify prose, though it is low priority

2. Crutch Words

Crutch words are personal favorites used so often they lose meaning. Find them by frequency, not by generic lists, and keep those that do deliberate character or voice work.

  • Examples: just, really, actually, suddenly, honestly
  • Gestures can also be crutches, such as smirking or sighing
  • Tools: free word frequency counter, Copilot in Word, or searching one word at a time in a word processor
  • Author voice is crafted through revision, not first-draft autopilot prose
  • Keep crutches that do character work, such as a narrator who says honestly all the time

3. Echo Words

Echo words are noticeable words repeated within a few lines unintentionally. Listen with read-aloud tools to catch them and change one instance, usually the second.

  • Example: 'The kitchen was dim. Kate felt her way down the dim hallway.'
  • Fix by changing one instance, e.g., narrow hallway, or cutting the adjective
  • Common words like said or character names do not count; deliberate repetition for rhythm stays

4. Stock Phrases

Stock phrases are pre-written clichés such as 'let out a breath she didn't know she was holding'. Replace them with the specific physical response of the character in that moment.

  • Examples: a shiver ran down her spine; his heart pounded in his chest
  • Test: read the first half aloud; if someone cannot finish it, it's a cliché
  • Replace with the character's specific action, e.g., sitting down on the bottom step

5. Hedging

Hedging softens statements that do not need softening. Search for hedge words and ask whose uncertainty it is: the character's (keep) or the writer's (cut).

  • Hedge words: seemed, sort of, kind of, a little, somewhat, almost, perhaps, could be argued, may
  • Search list: seemed, sort of, kind of, a little, somewhat, almost, perhaps
  • Aaron seemed nervous fails in Aaron's close third POV but works in Austin's POV because Austin must guess
  • In nonfiction, state a mixed evidence claim once plainly rather than hedging repeatedly

6. Filter Words

Filter words are perception verbs that place a character between the reader and events. Remove them unless the noticing itself is the point or the character might be wrong.

  • Filter words: saw, heard, felt, noticed, realized, watched, could see, could hear
  • Example: 'Hannah heard the front door slam' becomes 'The front door slammed'
  • Keep filters when noticing is the point, e.g., 'It was an hour before Hannah noticed the keys were gone'
  • Keep filters when the character might be wrong, e.g., 'She thought she heard the door'

7. Filler Words

Filler words take up space without adding meaning, such as 'started to' and 'that'. Remove them, but check each instance rather than running a blanket find-and-replace.

  • Example: 'a dog that started to bark in order to warn them' (13 words) becomes 'a dog barked a warning' (5 words)
  • Started to and began to: keep only when action is interrupted (e.g., Tony started to answer and she cut him off)
  • 'She started to walk to the door' becomes 'She walked to the door'
  • 'He knew that she was lying' becomes 'He knew she was lying'
  • Do not run find-and-replace on every 'that'

8. Over-Explaining

Over-explaining repeats what the reader has already understood, either by explaining a shown action or having characters say things only for the reader's benefit.

  • Example: 'Kate slammed the door. She was furious with him.' The explanation is unnecessary
  • Dialogue example: 'Sarah, you've lived in this town your whole life. You know how people talk.'
  • Fiction test: highlight sentences that interpret a preceding action or dialogue, cover them, and see if the reader still understands
  • Dialogue fix: ask whether the character would say it aloud to that person; otherwise find another way, such as a newcomer asking or a fight
  • Nonfiction test: read only the first sentence of each paragraph; cut paragraphs that repeat a point

9. Head Hopping

Head hopping shifts POV within a scene without a break, confusing the reader. Use two highlighter colors to check; fix by rewriting from the POV character's outside view.

  • Example: Aaron wondered if he could tell she'd been crying, then Austin thought she looked tired, in one scene without a break
  • Check: highlight each POV character's thoughts in a different color; one scene with both colors and no break is a hop
  • Fix example: 'Austin looked at her a beat too long' from Aaron's POV
  • Omniscient POV is less common today; it has a consistent narrator voice, while head hopping is a slipping close third
  • Reasons omniscient is less common: modern readers prefer close deep POV, it can feel distant, and it is hard to master

10. Named Emotions

Named emotions label feelings directly, such as 'Nicole was nervous.' Replace labels with what the character does or says that reveals the feeling, unless naming it serves pacing.

  • Example: 'Nicole was nervous about the interview' versus reading the address twice and taking the phone back out
  • Search emotion words: angry, nervous, scared, relieved, embarrassed, frustrated
  • Naming an emotion can be right during quick transitions where the feeling is not the point
  • Author discernment rather than a blanket rule

11. Walls of Text

Walls of text are solid gray blocks of paragraphs that tire the reader. Break paragraphs at every speaker change and at shifts in attention, though slow reflective passages can work.

  • Spot by zooming out until several pages are visible and looking for solid gray pages
  • Rule: new speaker, new paragraph every time
  • Break paragraphs when attention shifts, e.g., from an argument to the rain
  • Book formatting uses smaller pages than standard documents, making walls more severe
  • Slow reflective passages can justify long paragraphs

12. Tense Slips

Tense slips occur when a narrative switches tense unintentionally. Search for verbs in the opposite tense and use past perfect for flashbacks, while dialogue keeps its natural tense.

  • Example: 'She walks into the kitchen and grabbed a mug.'
  • In past tense manuscripts, search for present forms like says, walks, looks, turns
  • In present tense manuscripts, search for said, walked
  • Flashbacks use past perfect (had) to step in, simple past for the scene, and one had to step back out
  • Example: 'Tony had met her at a wedding. He'd spilled wine on her shoes...'
  • Dialogue may remain in its natural tense, e.g., 'I hate this town, she said.'

13. Fancy Dialogue Tags

Fancy dialogue tags like hissed, scoffed, or exclaimed pull attention from the line. Use said or asked unless the tag adds volume or the line cannot convey tone on its own.

  • Examples: hissed, exclaimed, retorted, chortled, interjected
  • You cannot hiss or scoff words; replace with a separate action and period, e.g., 'He scoffed. That's not what I meant.'
  • Keep whispered and shouted because they convey volume that words cannot
  • Search for every tag that is not said or asked and check whether the line already conveys the tone

14. Tagging Every Line

Tagging every line makes dialogue slow and repetitive. Once only two speakers are involved, tags and names can often be removed. With three or more speakers, more tags are needed.

  • Example exchange shows Adam and Kate with a tag on every line that could be removed
  • Characters repeatedly using each other's names is unnatural
  • Exercise: copy a two-person conversation, delete tags and names, and have a friend mark speakers; restore tags where they guess wrong
  • Add tags after long narration to avoid losing place
  • With three or more speakers, use varied tags and actions, but only one per dialogue turn

15. Continuity Errors

Continuity errors are inconsistencies in facts such as eye color, names, days, or object placement. Keep a style sheet tracking fixed facts and check details during revision.

  • Examples: green eyes turning brown, a name spelled differently, Tuesday becoming Thursday, sitting down twice without standing
  • Golden Editorial copy editors keep a style guide of fixed facts
  • Style sheet items: character name spellings, ages, eye color, physical traits, vehicles, and chapter day and time
  • Do a separate pass tracking where characters are and what is in their hands
  • Even careful self-edits will still leave some continuity errors for copy editors

Conclusion and Course Promotion

Self-editing is an essential, unskippable stage of writing, mostly rewriting and revising. After self-editing come alpha and beta readers, deciding editing types, publishing path, and working with an editor, covered in the promoted course.

  • Most authors realize writing is largely rewriting and revising only after their first draft
  • Self-editing is followed by alpha and beta readers, choosing editing type, publishing path, and professional editing
  • The Golden Editorial Guide to Book Editing covers the full editing process from first draft to publish ready